BJP alleges ₹133 crore Bengaluru waste tender given to ineligible firm
Synopsis
Key Takeaways
Karnataka Opposition Leader R. Ashoka on Saturday, 24 October alleged that the state's Congress government awarded a ₹133 crore waste management tender to an ineligible company in Bengaluru, accusing officials of bypassing eligibility rules and waiving mandatory security deposits in exchange for kickbacks. Ashoka made the allegations at a press conference, releasing documents he claimed substantiate the irregularities.
The Tender in Question
The tender, floated by the Bruhat Bengaluru Mahanagara Palike (BBMP) for waste collection and transfer stations, was reportedly awarded to Muniyappa Enterprises. According to Ashoka, the company lacks a GST registration number and is allegedly a benami firm. State government rules introduced in 2018 required bidders to have a minimum annual turnover of ₹10 crore. Muniyappa Enterprises, he alleged, posted a turnover of only ₹3.34 crore in 2023-24, and had recorded just ₹1–2 crore annually in prior years. 'Eligibility conditions were violated to take a 40 per cent commission,' Ashoka charged.
Security Deposits Allegedly Waived
Ashoka further alleged that the Bengaluru Solid Waste Management Limited (BSWML) issued work orders without collecting mandatory additional security deposits — even after the Finance Department had issued a formal warning. In Package 2, he said, an additional deposit of ₹6.79 crore against an estimated cost of ₹55.04 crore was waived. In Package 5, a deposit of ₹5.99 crore was not collected. In total, ₹12.99 crore in security deposits was allegedly foregone. The Letter of Acceptance (LoA) was issued on 22 May, reportedly in defiance of the Finance Department's directions.
Process Violations Alleged
Ashoka alleged that land for the proposed waste transfer stations was never identified before tenders for 21 packages were floated — a procedural lapse he described as deliberate. He claimed that more eligible companies existed but were not invited for negotiations, which the BBMP Commissioner or Urban Development Department Commissioner was obligated to conduct to bring down rates. 'Rules were bypassed to loot,' he said. He also flagged operational concerns, noting that autos transporting waste would need to travel 8–10 km, making even two trips per day unviable.
Political Charges and Demands
Ashoka invoked the name of Deputy Chief Minister D.K. Shivakumar — whom he referred to as 'Real Estate CM' — recalling that Shivakumar had once invited citizens to call him directly if anyone demanded a bribe, but had never made his number public. He also pointed to Minister Krishna Byregowda, who had launched a 'Freedom from Waste' campaign upon taking charge of the Bengaluru Development portfolio, and alleged that the campaign had been replaced in practice by a 'Money from Waste' scheme. Ashoka demanded that all files related to Packages 2 and 5 be seized immediately and the matter referred to the Lokayukta for a high-level investigation.
Citizen Impact and Centre's Role
Ashoka noted that waste collection fees for flat residents in Bengaluru had risen from ₹40 to ₹400, with officials allegedly threatening to suspend daily waste clearance for non-payment. He added that the Centre provides funds for such projects under the Swachh Bharat Mission, and alleged that when such funds arrive, state officials extract commissions. He said he has met Union Home Minister Amit Shah, who reportedly asked to be briefed on Karnataka's political developments every two to three months, and that he would continue to do so. Ashoka warned that if Chief Minister D.K. Shivakumar does not cancel the tender after receiving his written demand, 'it will be confirmed that the Chief Minister also has a share in this.'
The Congress government in Karnataka is yet to formally respond to the specific allegations. The matter is expected to escalate as the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) prepares to formally write to the Chief Minister seeking cancellation of the tender.