Punjab Education Minister flags BJP's 7-year-old school video as misleading
Synopsis
Key Takeaways
Punjab Education Minister Harjot Bains on Thursday, 20 August accused Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) leaders of circulating a seven-year-old video of a government school as current footage, calling it a deliberate attempt to malign Punjab's education record. Bains said he personally visited the school in question to verify the claims on the ground.
The Video and the Ground Visit
The video, shared on X by BJP national spokesperson Pradeep Bhandari and later reposted by Member of Parliament Harbhajan Singh, purportedly showed the poor condition of a Punjab government school. Bains said that upon learning of the post, he visited Jallah Government School in Fatehgarh Sahib — the institution shown in the footage — and found the situation had changed completely.
The school now has smart interactive panels, functional toilets, a sanitary pad incinerator, clean drinking water, and wi-fi, according to Bains. 'Political criticism is part of public life, but deliberate attempts to malign Punjab and its schools will not be tolerated,' he said.
Punjab's Education Performance Record
Countering the BJP's narrative, Bains cited a series of independent national assessments. He said Punjab had topped the country in the Performance Grading Index (PGI) 2.0 and that the NITI Aayog report released in May ranked Punjab number one in classroom learning outcomes. The PARAKH Rashtriya Sarvekshan 2024 also placed Punjab first in education nationally, he added.
Bains further noted that the Ministry of Education's Project Approval Board had repeatedly appreciated Punjab's progress in school infrastructure and learning outcomes. He said even Patiala, ranked 23rd within Punjab, had outscored Gurugram — the top-ranked district in BJP-ruled Haryana — in the NITI Aayog survey.
NEET Results and Competitive Exam Performance
On student outcomes, Bains said 882 students from Punjab government schools had cleared UG-NEET 2026 in national-level competitive examinations. He framed this as evidence of a broader transformation, invoking a shift from the 'Udta Punjab' narrative to what he described as 'Pardha Punjab'.
'Today, 882 students of government schools have cracked UG-NEET 2026. Punjab's performance in education is being acknowledged nationally,' he said.
The Political Context
The episode reflects an ongoing information battle between the Aam Aadmi Party (AAP)-led Punjab government and the BJP ahead of future electoral cycles. This is not the first time that old or decontextualised visuals have been flagged in Indian political discourse — the practice of recycling dated footage to frame current government performance has drawn repeated fact-checks across party lines. Bains was emphatic that criticism of him personally was acceptable, but that attempts to damage Punjab's reputation would not go unchallenged. 'The issue is not Harjot Bains. The issue is Punjab,' he said.