Pakistan champions press freedom at Baku forum, jails journalists at home
Synopsis
Key Takeaways
Pakistan has been actively championing press freedom on the international stage while simultaneously maintaining one of the most hostile environments for journalists domestically, according to a report published in Greek City Times by analyst Paul Antonopoulos. The report details Islamabad's participation in the inaugural Conference on Interaction and Confidence Building Measures in Asia (CICA) Media Forum held in Baku, Azerbaijan, where Pakistan's delegation pushed for journalist exchange programmes and media cooperation frameworks.
Pakistan's Pitch at the Baku Forum
Pakistan's delegation to the CICA Media Forum was led by Minister of State for Federal Education and Professional Training, Wajiha Qamar. In her remarks, Qamar argued that media has the power to either widen divisions between societies or bridge them, adding that Pakistan chooses the latter path. She called for a sustained CICA framework encompassing journalist exchanges, joint documentaries, content-sharing arrangements, and collaborative digital platforms.
However, Antonopoulos noted a significant irony in Pakistan's choice of partner. 'Islamabad used the occasion to negotiate journalist exchanges, fellowships and fact-checking cooperation with Azerbaijan, a state that currently holds at least 30 journalists in prison and whose president Reporters Without Borders lists among its press freedom predators,' he wrote. As the report pointedly observed, 'When two governments that jail reporters agree to train each other's journalists, the subject under discussion is not press freedom. It is the control of information.'
Pakistan's Press Freedom Record in Numbers
Reporters Without Borders ranked Pakistan at 153rd out of 180 countries in the 2026 World Press Freedom Index. Pakistani officials portrayed this as an improvement over the previous year. What they did not mention, according to the report, is that Reporters Without Borders itself described 2026 as the worst year for the press since the index began, with press freedom declining in 100 of the 180 countries surveyed. A marginal upward movement in such a year, the report argued, reflects a slower rate of deterioration rather than genuine progress.
The Pakistan Press Foundation recorded at least 233 incidents targeting journalists and media professionals between January 2025 and April 2026. These included 67 criminal complaints, 67 assaults, 11 arrests, 11 detentions, and 3 kidnappings. Of the criminal complaints, 34 were filed under the Prevention of Electronic Crimes Act (PECA). Notably, Pakistani human rights lawyers Imaan Zainab Mazari-Hazir and Hadi Ali Chattha, who represented journalists in cybercrime cases, were themselves sentenced to up to 17 years in prison under the same statute.
A Year of Violence and Lawfare
An Islamabad-based media watchdog separately documented 97 violations against media practitioners between October 2025 and August 2026, characterising Pakistan as a 'deeply hostile environment for journalism' despite a marginal reduction in documented cases. The Freedom Network's annual Impunity Report 2026, titled 'From Violence to Lawfare: Process as Punishment for Journalists', recorded one work-related killing, three attempted assassinations, 18 murder or harm threats, 13 legal actions, 32 threats of legal action, and 11 assaults over the same period.
The pattern suggests a shift in tactics — from direct physical violence toward the use of legal mechanisms to silence journalists, a trend the Freedom Network described as 'lawfare.'
The Contradiction at the Top
The report highlighted a stark contradiction in the statements of Pakistan's own leadership. On World Press Freedom Day this year, President Asif Ali Zardari remarked that public trust is the most valuable asset of a free press and must be earned, protected, and never taken for granted. Antonopoulos noted that his government and the security establishment spent the same twelve months doing the opposite.
'Pakistan is free to advocate for press freedom internationally while doing exactly the opposite at home,' the report concluded, characterising the Baku framework not as genuine media diplomacy but as 'an arrangement between two countries that imprisons journalists to exchange personnel, content and technique.' The divergence between Pakistan's international posture and domestic record is likely to draw continued scrutiny from global press freedom organisations.