SC tells Sanjay Raut apology must come 'from heart' in CJI contempt case

Share:
Audio Loading voice…
SC tells Sanjay Raut apology must come 'from heart' in CJI contempt case

Synopsis

The Supreme Court pointedly told Sanjay Raut that an apology 'from the mind' won't do — it must come 'from the heart.' With the SCBA flagging Raut's subsequent remarks about Albanian court burnings as aggravating conduct, and both contemnors ordered to file fresh affidavits before 8 December, the case is now a test of whether public figures can walk back judicial criticism on their own terms.

Key Takeaways

The Supreme Court told Sanjay Raut on 17 November that an apology in this matter must come 'from the heart and not the mind.' A Bench of Justice Aravind Kumar and Justice Vipul M.
Pancholi noted Raut's standing as a seasoned parliamentarian made greater restraint expected of him.
Nikhil Wagle's counsel said he had already issued an unconditional apology and deleted the controversial post, seeking closure of proceedings.
The Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA) flagged Raut's subsequent social media posts on the burning of the Supreme Court of Albania as relevant aggravating conduct.
Both Raut and Wagle have been directed to file additional affidavits; the next hearing is on 8 December .
The case stems from Raut's 12 October claim that he saw 60 to 70 judges , including CJI Surya Kant , playing badminton with BJP leaders in London.

The Supreme Court on Tuesday, 17 November 2026, told Shiv Sena (UBT) Rajya Sabha member Sanjay Raut that an apology in a matter of such gravity must come 'from the heart and not the mind', as it heard criminal contempt proceedings against him and senior journalist Nikhil Wagle over their alleged remarks targeting Chief Justice of India (CJI) Surya Kant. The court has directed both to file additional affidavits and return on 8 December.

What the Court Said

A Bench of Justice Aravind Kumar and Justice Vipul M. Pancholi observed that Raut, as an experienced parliamentarian and seasoned politician, was expected to exercise a higher degree of restraint and responsibility in public statements. 'Mr Sanjay Raut, you are a seasoned politician. We have been hearing your speeches from your advocate days. You are a seasoned parliamentarian, and you yourself were in the press. You should know what restraint is expected,' the Justice Kumar-led Bench said. The court further noted that individuals occupying positions of public trust must demonstrate commensurate responsibility.

Raut Present in Court, Wagle Joins Virtually

Raut appeared physically before the apex court as directed, while Wagle joined the proceedings via video conferencing. Senior advocate Indira Jaising, representing Wagle, submitted that her client had already tendered an unconditional apology and deleted the controversial social media post, urging the court to close proceedings against him. However, senior advocate Pradeep Rai, appearing for the Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA), argued that Raut had continued making objectionable remarks about the judiciary even after the initial controversy.

The Subsequent Posts at Issue

Rai contended that Raut's affidavit failed to address his later social media posts concerning the burning of the Supreme Court of Albania, arguing those remarks were directly relevant to the contempt proceedings. He submitted that while Raut had apologised for his initial statement, his subsequent conduct remained a matter of serious concern for the court. Taking note of these submissions, the Bench directed both Raut and Wagle to file additional affidavits detailing their respective positions before the next hearing.

Background: The Badminton Remark and Its Fallout

The controversy originated on 12 October, when Raut allegedly claimed during a media interaction that he had seen 60 to 70 judges, including the CJI, playing badminton with Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) leaders in London. The remarks came shortly after CJI Surya Kant declined to meet Leader of Opposition Rahul Gandhi and Congress president Mallikarjun Kharge, who had sought an appointment to submit a memorandum on the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls. The CJI had observed that such a meeting to discuss pending cases would violate the constitutional principle of separation of powers. The SCBA subsequently filed a criminal contempt petition, prompting the apex court to issue notice to both Raut and Wagle on 16 October.

What Happens Next

The apex court has adjourned the matter to 8 December and directed both proposed contemnors to remain present in court on that date. The additional affidavits they file are expected to shape the court's assessment of whether the apologies tendered are sufficient in substance and sincerity. The outcome of this case is being closely watched for the signal it sends about the limits of public speech by elected representatives and journalists concerning the judiciary.

Point of View

Not the mind' — signals it is not prepared to treat a pro-forma regret as sufficient discharge in a case touching the institutional reputation of the CJI. The SCBA's move to place Raut's subsequent Albania-related posts on record is a tactical escalation that could make a clean exit harder for him. More broadly, this case sits at a delicate intersection: elected politicians and journalists have long tested the limits of judicial criticism, and the court's handling here will set a tone for how far that latitude extends when the target is the sitting Chief Justice. The separation-of-powers backdrop — the CJI's refusal to meet Rahul Gandhi and Kharge — adds political texture that neither side can fully ignore.
NationPress
17 Nov 2026

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the contempt case against Sanjay Raut and Nikhil Wagle about?
The criminal contempt proceedings were initiated by the Supreme Court following a petition by the Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA) over remarks Raut and Wagle allegedly made against Chief Justice of India Surya Kant. The case centres on Raut's claim on 12 October that he had seen 60 to 70 judges, including the CJI, playing badminton with BJP leaders in London.
What did the Supreme Court tell Sanjay Raut at the 17 November hearing?
The court told Raut that an apology in a matter of this magnitude must come 'from the heart and not the mind.' The Bench also reminded him that as a seasoned parliamentarian and former journalist, he was expected to exercise greater restraint while making public statements.
What is Nikhil Wagle's current position in the case?
Wagle's senior counsel Indira Jaising submitted that he had already tendered an unconditional apology and deleted the controversial social media post, and urged the court to close proceedings against him. The court, however, has asked him to file an additional affidavit before the next hearing on 8 December.
Why did the SCBA raise concerns about Raut's subsequent social media posts?
The Supreme Court Bar Association's counsel Pradeep Rai argued that Raut had continued making objectionable remarks about the judiciary after the initial controversy, specifically citing social media posts about the burning of the Supreme Court of Albania. The SCBA contended these subsequent posts were relevant to the contempt proceedings and reflected a pattern of conduct, not an isolated remark.
What happens next in the contempt case?
The Supreme Court has adjourned the matter to 8 December and directed both Sanjay Raut and Nikhil Wagle to file additional affidavits explaining their positions. Both have also been asked to appear in person before the court on that date.
Nation Press
The Trail

Connected Dots

Tracing the thread behind this story — newest first.

8 Dots
  1. Latest 2 weeks ago
  2. 4 weeks ago
  3. 1 month ago
  4. 1 month ago
  5. 3 months ago
  6. 3 months ago
  7. 5 months ago
  8. 9 months ago
Google Prefer NP
On Google