Is Selective and Unverified Reporting Harming the Air India Crash Investigation?
Click to start listening
Synopsis
The AAIB warns that unverified reports from international media may undermine the investigation into the Air India crash. As accusations of pilot error circulate, experts call for a more responsible discourse. Discover the implications of this reporting on the ongoing inquiry.
Key Takeaways
- AAIB warns against irresponsible media coverage.
- Current investigation is ongoing and conclusions are premature.
- Calls for expert involvement in the investigation process.
- Importance of fact-based discourse emphasized.
- Flight crew deserves respect for their efforts during the incident.
New Delhi, July 17 (NationPress) As some international media outlets persist in disseminating unverified and false information regarding the Air India Ahmedabad crash, the Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau (AAIB) issued a warning on Thursday against such selective and unverified reporting, describing it as irresponsible and potentially harmful to the investigation’s integrity.
The AAIB's response came after the Wall Street Journal (WSJ) claimed that a cockpit recording from the ill-fated Air India flight, which crashed last month, supposedly suggests that the captain cut off fuel supply to the aircraft's engines.
“We have observed that certain segments of the international media are consistently attempting to draw conclusions based on selective and unverified reporting,” stated the AAIB.
“Such behavior is reckless, particularly while the investigation is still underway. We implore both the public and the media to avoid spreading premature narratives that could jeopardize the integrity of the investigative process,” the bureau added.
“At this juncture, it is premature to arrive at any definitive conclusions. The AAIB's investigation is ongoing. The Final Investigation Report will provide root causes and recommendations,” it concluded.
Earlier in the day, the Federation of Indian Pilots (FIP) communicated in a letter to the Civil Aviation Ministry that the AAIB’s preliminary report on the Air India crash in Ahmedabad has inadequately accounted for two plausible technical scenarios that could have caused an automatic shutdown of both engines on the affected Boeing 787 Dreamliner.
The association has requested that the Civil Aviation Ministry involve additional subject matter experts in the inquiry. The pilots' group has claimed that the preliminary report appears to imply pilot error without presenting any concrete evidence or exploring previously documented technical failures observed in similar aircraft.
Additionally, the pilots' organization ALPA-India emphasized on Thursday that the crew of the crashed AI-171 flight exerted every effort to safeguard the passengers onboard and deserves respect, not baseless character judgments.
“The crew of AI-171 did everything possible -- until their last breath -- to protect the passengers onboard and minimize harm on the ground. They deserve respect, not unfounded character assessments,” ALPA India stated. “We reiterate our call for a fact-based and respectful dialogue,” the association said.
Point of View
It is imperative to highlight that while the investigation into the Air India crash is ongoing, we must rely on verified information. The integrity of the investigative process is crucial, and it is our responsibility to promote a discourse based on facts rather than speculation.
NationPress
17/07/2025
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the AAIB's stance on media reports?
The AAIB has criticized selective and unverified reporting by certain international media, stating it's irresponsible and could harm the investigation's integrity.
What did the Wall Street Journal report about the crash?
The WSJ reported that a cockpit recording suggested the captain may have cut off fuel supply to the engines, which the AAIB has not confirmed.
What did the Federation of Indian Pilots say?
The FIP indicated that the AAIB's preliminary report did not adequately consider technical scenarios that could have led to the crash.
How did ALPA-India respond?
ALPA-India stated that the flight crew made every effort to protect passengers and should not face unfounded character judgments.
What is the next step in the investigation?
The AAIB is conducting a thorough investigation and will release a Final Investigation Report outlining root causes and recommendations.
