Second Italian Senator backs condemnation of Filibeck's remarks on Indian democracy
Synopsis
Key Takeaways
Senator Giulio Terzi, Chair of the Italy–India Inter-Parliamentary Union (IPU) Bilateral Friendship Group, on Monday, 16 November 2026, publicly endorsed a statement by Forza Italia leader Deborah Bergamini criticising fellow Italian lawmaker Giacomo Filibeck — Secretary-General of the Party of European Socialists (PES) — over remarks he made about Indian democracy at an event in Hyderabad. The endorsement marks the second high-profile rebuke within Italian parliamentary circles of Filibeck's intervention in India's domestic political debate.
What Terzi Said
In a post on X, Terzi shared a screenshot of Bergamini's earlier statement and expressed his full support. 'As Chair of the Inter-Parliamentary Union's Italy–India Bilateral Friendship Group, I wish to fully endorse what Hon. Deborah Bergamini said yesterday... about an incident that, unfortunately, does nothing to foster the open, civil and constructive dialogue and mutual respect that must always characterize parliamentary diplomacy, too, and above all,' Terzi wrote. He made clear that Filibeck's remarks were incompatible with the norms of parliamentary diplomacy between friendly nations.
The Filibeck Controversy at Bharat Summit 2026
The row traces back to the Bharat Summit 2026, held in Hyderabad on 14 November 2026, where Filibeck shared a stage with Leader of the Opposition Rahul Gandhi. The summit was organised by the Indian National Congress (INC). During his address, Filibeck reportedly claimed that Indian democracy was 'under attack' and being 'hijacked'. He also echoed the Congress party's campaign slogan, 'Vote Chor, Gaddi Chhod' — meaning 'Vote thief, leave your seat' — a phrase directed at the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) and Prime Minister Narendra Modi.
Bergamini's Earlier Rebuke
Bergamini had criticised Filibeck in a statement posted on Facebook, calling his intervention inappropriate for a European representative at a meeting of an opposition party. 'An Italian representative from the European Socialists and Democrats group, while attending a meeting organised by the Indian National Congress party, attacked Prime Minister Modi's BJP, declaring: 'Vote thieves, step down from your seats',' she said. She added that Filibeck's comments came in the context of an ongoing controversy over the revision of India's electoral rolls — a process, she noted, aimed at updating voter lists by removing duplicate entries, names of deceased individuals, and those who have relocated.
Bergamini stressed that while democratic societies permit political parties and individuals to raise allegations, such claims must be supported by evidence. 'I believe that, in a democracy, everyone is free to put forward whatever arguments or accusations they choose — provided, of course, that they can substantiate them,' she said, adding that it was inappropriate for Europeans to lecture a nation that enables 970 million citizens to cast their votes.
India-Italy Strategic Partnership at Stake
Both Bergamini and Terzi underlined the significance of the India–Italy special strategic partnership, which fosters deep bilateral cooperation across sectors. Bergamini specifically argued that intervening in the domestic political debates of a country with which Italy has such a partnership was contrary to the spirit of that relationship. Notably, Terzi's role as the head of the bilateral parliamentary friendship group lends his rebuke institutional weight beyond a personal opinion. This comes amid a broader global debate over how democratic nations engage with each other's internal electoral processes — a conversation that has grown more sensitive as multilateral institutions grapple with questions of sovereignty and interference.
What Happens Next
There has been no public response from Filibeck to either Bergamini's or Terzi's statements as of Monday evening. The episode is likely to be watched closely by Indian diplomatic circles in Rome, given its timing ahead of further India–EU engagement discussions. Any formal response from the Party of European Socialists or the European Parliament could determine whether this remains a bilateral Italian political spat or escalates into a broader EU–India diplomatic issue.