Is Pakistan’s 3.7% Growth Figure Just an Accounting Mirage?
Click to start listening
Synopsis
A new report suggests that Pakistan's reported 3.7% economic growth in Q1 FY26 may not reflect real progress, but rather accounting adjustments and misleading data. With significant declines in food exports and import surges, the sustainability of this growth is in question.
Key Takeaways
- Pakistan's reported economic growth is under scrutiny.
- The 3.7% growth may be due to accounting adjustments.
- Manufacturing and exports are struggling.
- Food exports have significantly dropped.
- There is a growing concern about sustainable growth.
New Delhi, Jan 5 (NationPress) The official report from Pakistan indicating a 3.7% economic growth in the first quarter of FY26 is likely more of an accounting illusion rather than a reflection of tangible increases in production or exports, according to a recent analysis.
The Express Tribune highlighted insights from the think tank Economic Policy and Business Development (EPBD), which argues that the growth figure recognized by the National Accounts Committee (NAC) is a result of “methodological artefacts, deflator manipulation, and import-led assembly activity,” rather than genuine enhancements in productive capability.
This forum described the data as a deceptive portrayal of recovery, emphasizing that business activities, manufacturing output, and exports continue to face significant challenges.
Primarily, the official industrial growth rate of 9.4% has been largely attributed to accounting modifications, as noted by the think tank. The sectors of electricity, gas, and water supply reportedly saw a 25% growth, but this was primarily driven by an increase in subsidies from PKR 20 billion to PKR 118 billion, rather than genuine production increases.
The claim of a 21% growth in construction is also questioned, since cement production only increased by 15%, while imports related to transport notably surged, particularly bus and truck imports.
Additionally, food exports witnessed a drastic decline of 25.8% in Q1 FY26, whereas food imports rose by 18.8%. Despite these figures, agriculture and food manufacturing were reported to have expanded, with agriculture purportedly growing by 2.9% despite challenges from flooding, stagnant crop yields, and the absence of a wheat harvest in the quarter.
EPBD pointed out significant discrepancies between the proclaimed domestic growth and actual trade indicators. The report indicated that imports increased by 11% in the first half of the year, while exports diminished by approximately 9%, raising concerns over the sustainability of private-sector-driven growth.
Cotton production faced a decline, with ginning falling by over 12% and cotton-based exports dropping by around 10%, further underscoring the challenges within the economy.
Point of View
It's crucial to approach the economic claims made by Pakistan's government with a critical lens. While growth is always welcome, the discrepancies highlighted by the Economic Policy and Business Development think tank suggest a need for transparency and accuracy in reporting. Only with honest assessments can sustainable growth be achieved.
NationPress
08/01/2026
Frequently Asked Questions
What does the 3.7% growth figure represent?
The 3.7% growth figure is an official statistic from Pakistan, but analysts suggest it may be misleading, representing accounting adjustments rather than actual economic progress.
What are the main concerns regarding this growth figure?
Concerns include that the growth reflects accounting manipulations and that key sectors like manufacturing and exports are under significant pressure, indicating a lack of real recovery.
How have imports and exports been affected?
Imports rose by 11%, while exports dropped by around 9%, highlighting a troubling gap between claimed domestic growth and actual trade performance.
What impact has this had on the agriculture sector?
Despite claims of growth in agriculture, food exports fell sharply by 25.8%, raising questions about the actual state of the sector amidst reported flood impacts.
Should investors be concerned about these findings?
Yes, these findings suggest a lack of sustainable growth, which could be a red flag for investors considering the health of Pakistan's economy.
