Has Trump Softened His 'Lost India' Comment While Affirming Ties with PM Modi?
Click to start listening
Synopsis
In a recent press conference, President Trump appeared to retract his previous comments about 'losing' India to China, emphasizing his strong relationship with PM Modi while expressing disappointment over India's Russian oil purchases. This evolving narrative raises questions about US-India relations in the context of global politics.
Key Takeaways
- Trump's comments reflect a nuanced view of US-India relations.
- Concerns over India's oil purchases from Russia persist.
- High tariffs may strain economic ties.
- India remains committed to sourcing oil based on its interests.
- Dialogue between the US and India is crucial for future relations.
Washington, Sep 6 (NationPress) US President Donald Trump has seemingly softened his earlier statement regarding the notion of having "lost" India to China.
During a press briefing at the White House on Friday, when asked if he held anyone accountable for "losing India to China," Trump replied, "I don't think we have."
He emphasized that he shares a good relationship with Prime Minister Modi but expressed his disappointment over India's decision to purchase Russian oil.
"I've been quite disheartened that India is acquiring a significant amount of oil from Russia, and I've made it clear that we imposed a substantial tariff on India, a 50 percent tariff, a very steep tariff," he remarked.
Earlier that day, Trump shared an image featuring PM Modi alongside Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin, commenting that India and Russia appear to have been "lost" to China.
"It seems we've lost India and Russia to the depths of China. Wishing them a long and prosperous future together!" he posted on his social media platform, 'Truth Social'.
This statement comes amid a surge of critical comments directed at India from his administration and its supporters.
White House Advisor Peter Navarro reiterated his allegations on Friday, claiming on X that India's "high tariffs are detrimental to US jobs."
Trump's aide, Laura Loomer, suggested on X that the administration is "evaluating the possibility of restricting US IT companies from outsourcing work to Indian firms," although she did not provide any supporting evidence.
In a Bloomberg interview on Friday, US Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick stated that the "US is always open to dialogue," but seemed to establish conditions for India.
"India is not yet ready to open their market. They need to stop purchasing Russian oil, right? And cease being part of BRICS, correct? They represent the link between Russia and China. If that's the path they choose, so be it. But they need to either support the Dollar, the United States of America, and their biggest client, the American consumer, or they might face a 50 percent tariff. Let's see how long that lasts," he added.
Lutnick also expressed US discontent regarding India's growing reliance on Russian crude oil, labeling it as "plain wrong."
On Friday, India's Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman affirmed that India will persist in buying Russian oil.
"We have to decide where we source our oil from, especially with such a significant foreign exchange expenditure, and we will choose what is most beneficial for us," she stated in an interview with an Indian media outlet.
"We will definitely continue purchasing," she concluded.
Point of View
It is crucial to recognize the delicate balance in US-India relations. While President Trump's comments may reflect political posturing, the underlying issues of trade and diplomacy are far more complex. It is essential for both nations to engage in constructive dialogue to strengthen their partnership while addressing concerns over tariffs and oil imports.
NationPress
26/12/2025
Frequently Asked Questions
What did Trump mean by 'losing' India to China?
Trump's statement suggests a concern that India is aligning more closely with China, particularly in economic terms.
What was India's response to Trump's comments?
India's Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman affirmed that India will continue to buy Russian oil despite US concerns.
How has the US reacted to India's oil purchases?
The US has expressed disappointment and imposed tariffs, indicating that India's actions could have economic repercussions.
What are the implications of high tariffs on India?
High tariffs could impact trade relations between the US and India, potentially affecting jobs and economic growth in both countries.
Is there ongoing dialogue between the US and India?
Yes, US officials have stated they are open to discussions, but conditions need to be met by India regarding trade practices.
