AIMIM questions Siraj's exclusion from India XI: 'Selection must be talent-based'
Synopsis
Key Takeaways
The All India Majlis-e-Ittehadul Muslimeen (AIMIM) on Saturday, 21 November weighed in on the growing controversy surrounding Mohammed Siraj's omission from India's playing XI for the first Test against New Zealand, asserting that cricket selection must be driven by talent and performance — not a player's name or identity. The remarks came as the debate over the team management's pace-bowling choices drew political attention from multiple quarters.
The Selection That Sparked the Debate
Siraj, India's leading wicket-taker in the ongoing World Test Championship (WTC) cycle, was left out of the playing XI for the first Test on Thursday. The team management opted for young pacer Anshul Kamboj in a pace-heavy combination alongside Jasprit Bumrah, Prasidh Krishna, and Akash Deep, with Siraj named among the reserves. The decision prompted immediate scrutiny over the rationale behind the selection strategy.
What AIMIM's Waris Pathan Said
AIMIM National Spokesperson Waris Pathan questioned the selection, drawing parallels with the cases of Sarfaraz Khan and Mohammed Shami. 'My belief is that earlier, Sarfaraz, he is from our Mumbai, he wasn't picked either. Earlier, he was told his body is heavy, this and that. He reduced his body, reduced his weight, and gave such good performance in domestic cricket. So why wasn't Sarfaraz picked? You didn't pick Shami,' Pathan said.
Pathan further argued that Siraj had consistently delivered for the national side, including stepping up during periods when Bumrah was unavailable. 'Mohammed Siraj was playing positive cricket, was giving good performances, was a good help to the team in place of Bumrah; whenever the team needed him, he gave good performances. Why wasn't he picked? The selection should be based on talent and performance and not the name. On one hand, Jay Shah was made the head of BCCI without any talent and performance, and on the other hand, Sarfaraz, Shami and Siraj, all were dropped,' he added.
Congress MP's Earlier Remarks Fuel the Row
The AIMIM's statement follows remarks by Congress MP Imran Masood, who had alleged that Siraj was overlooked because of his religious identity. 'His name is Siraj — isn't that reason enough? If he is performing and still not getting selected, what else could be the reason? This alone can be the reason; there can be no other reason besides this,' Masood had claimed. Critics argue that such assertions risk politicising cricket selection decisions that are ordinarily within the domain of team management and selectors.
Team Management Defends the Call
India batting coach Sitanshu Kotak defended the selection, stating that the combination fielded for the first Test was considered the strongest possible by the captain and team management. The BCCI and selectors have not separately addressed the political commentary surrounding the decision.
Broader Context
This is not the first time India's pace-bowling selection has attracted scrutiny. The cases of Sarfaraz Khan's delayed Test debut and Shami's prolonged absence due to injury — and subsequent return to fitness — have previously been cited in debates about consistency in selection criteria. Notably, Siraj has been a frontline bowler across formats and his omission in a WTC cycle where wickets are at a premium has raised legitimate cricketing questions, separate from the political narrative now overlaying the issue.