Should the Calcutta HC Halt the Construction of a Babri Masjid-Style Mosque in Murshidabad?
Synopsis
A Public Interest Litigation has been filed in Calcutta HC to halt the construction of a Babri Masjid-style mosque in Murshidabad. This case raises crucial questions about communal harmony and political actions, especially given the contentious history behind the Babri Masjid.
Key Takeaways
The PIL seeks to halt the mosque's construction in Murshidabad.
Concerns over communal harmony and legal permissions have been raised.
Humayun Kabir, despite suspension, initiated the construction.
Legal arguments reference fundamental rights under the Constitution.
Mamata Banerjee opposes communal politics in the region.
Kolkata, Dec 10 (NationPress) A Public Interest Litigation (PIL) was submitted to the Calcutta High Court on Wednesday, requesting an order to cease the construction of a mosque resembling the Babri Masjid in the Murshidabad district, a project initiated by the suspended Trinamool Congress leader and Bharatpur MLA Humayun Kabir.
The PIL was presented before the bench led by Acting Chief Justice Sujoy Paul. The court has accepted the petition, and a hearing is anticipated next week.
The petitioner contends that the name Babri Masjid is associated with the highly contentious Babri Masjid-Ram Janmabhoomi dispute in Ayodhya.
This construction could potentially disturb the communal harmony in the state, leading to social unrest. Additionally, the petitioner questioned how Humayun Kabir, despite being suspended, is proceeding with construction without the district administration's approval.
It was argued that Kabir’s actions infringe upon the fundamental rights guaranteed by Articles 14, 21, and 25 of the Indian Constitution. Thus, the petitioner urged the court to promptly issue a stay on the mosque's construction.
Notably, controversy has surrounded Kabir's decision to lay the foundation stone of this mosque in Beldanga over the past week.
On December 4, the leadership of Trinamool Congress suspended Kabir from the party due to his alleged anti-party activities.
In defiance of his suspension, Kabir proceeded with the foundation-laying ceremony on December 6.
He announced that construction would commence in the first week of February in Beldanga, with recitation of the Quran by one lakh voices scheduled for the day before construction starts.
On December 4, West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee emphasized that the residents of Murshidabad would reject any form of communal politics. Her statement followed the suspension of Kabir, who was accused of fostering communal tension with his plans for the mosque.
During a public meeting in Berhampore, CM Banerjee remarked, "Trinamool Congress does not engage in communal politics and stands firmly against it. We must honor the historic legacy of Murshidabad, where figures like Siraj-ud-Daulah are cherished. This district is home to sacred sites of all religions, and its people will not tolerate politics inciting riots."
Point of View
This case underscores the delicate balance between religious freedom and communal harmony. While construction projects often evoke strong sentiments, it is essential to address these issues through dialogue and legal frameworks, ensuring that fundamental rights are upheld while preventing social discord. NationPress advocates for a peaceful resolution that respects both cultural heritage and community sentiments.
NationPress
6 Jul 2026
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the purpose of the PIL filed in Calcutta HC?
The PIL aims to prevent the construction of a mosque modeled after the Babri Masjid in Murshidabad, citing concerns over communal harmony and legal permissions.
Who is Humayun Kabir?
Humayun Kabir is a suspended leader of the Trinamool Congress and the MLA for Bharatpur, who initiated the mosque construction project.
What legal rights are being referenced in the PIL?
The PIL argues that the construction violates fundamental rights under Articles 14, 21, and 25 of the Indian Constitution.
What stance did Mamata Banerjee take on this issue?
Mamata Banerjee emphasized that the people of Murshidabad will not accept communal politics and reaffirmed the party's commitment to secular values.
When is the hearing for the PIL expected?
The hearing for the PIL is likely to take place next week following its admission by the Calcutta High Court.
