Why Are Muslim Clerics Condemning Cong's Dalwai Over PM Modi's Bhagavad Gita Gift to Putin?

Share:
Audio Loading voice…
Why Are Muslim Clerics Condemning Cong's Dalwai Over PM Modi's Bhagavad Gita Gift to Putin?

Synopsis

Muslim clerics have come forth in strong opposition to Congress leader Hussain Dalwai's critique of Prime Minister Modi's gift of the Bhagavad Gita to Putin, asserting that such criticisms are misguided. This article explores the implications of the gesture and the ensuing political discourse.

Key Takeaways

Muslim clerics condemned Congress leader Hussain Dalwai 's critique of PM Modi.
The Bhagavad Gita was gifted to Putin as a symbol of India's cultural diplomacy.
This gesture reflects India's soft-power heritage.
Criticism of the gesture has sparked a broader discussion on religion and politics.
Cultural exchanges can lead to misunderstandings in a politically charged atmosphere.

New Delhi, Dec 6 (NationPress) Muslim clerics expressed strong disapproval on Saturday against Congress leader Hussain Dalwai for his comments questioning Prime Minister Narendra Modi's choice to present a Russian edition of the Bhagavad Gita to President Vladimir Putin during his two-day visit to India. The clerics asserted that creating a controversy over this gesture was unwarranted and demonstrated a misdirected critique.

During his welcoming in New Delhi, Prime Minister Modi graciously gifted President Putin with the Russian version of the Bhagavad Gita, a revered Hindu scripture acknowledged globally. This act was widely interpreted as an affirmation of India's cultural strengths and a symbol of enhanced cultural, strategic, and economic partnerships with a long-time ally.

In response, Dalwai criticized the gesture, stating to IANS, "I do not comprehend the purpose behind presenting the Bhagavad Gita. Religious texts should remain separate from political and international matters; if that is the intention, then the Quran, the Bible, and the Guru Granth Sahib should also have been included."

Addressing the criticism, All India Imam Association president Maulana Sajid Rashidi remarked to IANS, "The underlying issue for the Congress's current decline is individuals like Dalwai, who pose such absurd and nonsensical questions. I question Hussain Dalwai: if you were to gift books to others, would you choose the Gita? No, you would choose the Quran, correct? Because you want to promote the Quran; you want people to read it. But a Hindu, through his beliefs, will naturally present the Gita; why would he offer the Quran?"

"When the Congress is supposed to represent the nation and its ideals, its leaders come forward with these unfounded statements. This is why the Congress has reached its current low point. They should recognize this statement and denounce it," he added.

Further criticizing Dalwai, Maulana Rashidi stated, "A Hindu by faith will inherently present the Bhagavad Gita. He does not hold faith in the Quran. If there were individuals like Sajid Rashidi, they would present the Quran. As seen, Maulana Rashid Mandari has distributed the Quran to many. The choice of book reflects a person's faith. To make this a controversy is erroneous."

He also mentioned that the visit conveyed a significant diplomatic message, saying, "This visit should be interpreted as a strong response to America, a nation that attempted to hinder India's progress through tariffs. PM Modi has sent a robust message to the US by warmly receiving Putin. Under these circumstances, the citizens should feel proud rather than raise unfounded questions."

All India Shia Personal Law Board General Secretary Maulana Yasoob Abbas also expressed disdain for Dalwai's remarks, indicating that a leader from a national party should not "misuse religion to mislead humanity."

In conversation with IANS, Maulana Abbas stated, "The Prime Minister gifted the Bhagavad Gita to President Putin as he was visiting a predominantly Hindu nation like India. When Putin visits any Islamic country, he may receive a Quran. In my perspective, this should not be politicized. This is not merely a Hindu-Muslim issue. Responsible authorities must address this matter, and the involved parties should refrain from using religion to mislead humanity."

Point of View

It is our duty to present a balanced view. The exchange surrounding PM Modi's gift to Putin raises important questions about the intertwining of religion and politics. While some perceive it as a cultural affirmation, others argue about the appropriateness of using religious texts in diplomatic gestures. It's crucial to foster respectful dialogue and understanding in such discussions.
NationPress
20 Jun 2026

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the significance of the Bhagavad Gita?
The Bhagavad Gita is a revered Hindu scripture that emphasizes moral and philosophical teachings, making it a symbol of India's cultural identity.
Why did PM Modi gift the Bhagavad Gita to Putin?
The gift was intended to showcase India's cultural heritage and strengthen ties with Russia during Putin's visit.
What was the reaction from Muslim clerics?
Muslim clerics criticized the remarks made by Congress leader Hussain Dalwai, emphasizing that such criticisms are misguided and demonstrate a misunderstanding of cultural gestures.
How do religious texts play a role in diplomacy?
Religious texts can serve as cultural symbols, but their use in political contexts can lead to controversy and misinterpretation.
What does this controversy reveal about political discourse in India?
This incident highlights ongoing tensions in political discourse, especially regarding the intersection of religion and politics in contemporary India.
Nation Press
The Trail

Connected Dots

Tracing the thread behind this story — newest first.

8 Dots
  1. Latest 6 months ago
  2. 6 months ago
  3. 6 months ago
  4. 6 months ago
  5. 6 months ago
  6. 6 months ago
  7. 6 months ago
  8. 6 months ago
Google Prefer NP
On Google