CM Sukhu Points to Nadda's Tender in MRI Machine Row
Synopsis
Key Takeaways
A procurement dispute over medical equipment in Himachal Pradesh just got a sharp political edge. Himachal Pradesh Chief Minister Sukhvinder Singh Sukhu, posting on X on Tuesday, November 17, 2026, deflected allegations of irregularities in state hospital equipment purchases — and aimed squarely at Union Health Minister J.P. Nadda.
What Sukhu Actually Said
Speaking in Hindi, the Chief Minister acknowledged two distinct procurement matters. First, he said the state had purchased a robotic surgery machine from AIIMS at a subsidised rate, noting that the then-director, Randhir Sharma, had family or village ties — an insinuation he left deliberately open. Second, and more pointedly, he addressed the installation of MRI machines at Nerchauk and IGMC (Indira Gandhi Medical College, Shimla), with a third unit scheduled to be installed at Tanda on the 20th.
His central counter-punch: the same MRI machines are installed at AIIMS Delhi, PGI, and several other premier institutions. And crucially, the purchase was made not by the state government but by a central government company — one that, Sukhu said explicitly, 'operates under the leadership of Health Minister Shri J.P. Naddaji.'
Sukhu's Line: 'Tender Is Theirs, Rate Contract Is Theirs'
'If there is any irregularity in this, ask Naddaji,' Sukhu stated. 'The tender is theirs and the rate contract is also theirs.' The argument is structurally clear: the Himachal Pradesh government purchased equipment through a central rate contract, meaning the pricing and vendor selection were determined at the Union level — not in Shimla.
This is not an unusual procurement route. Central government companies and ministries routinely set rate contracts for medical equipment that state governments and public hospitals draw upon. If the contract itself is flawed or overpriced, the accountability trail runs upward to the ministry that set it.
The Congress-BJP Health Infrastructure Battle in Himachal
The exchange fits a pattern that has defined Himachal politics since the Congress returned to power in December 2022. Health infrastructure — MRI machines, robotic surgery units, district hospital upgrades — has become a contested scorecard, with both state and central authorities claiming credit for gains and trading blame for gaps.
J.P. Nadda, a senior BJP leader himself from Himachal Pradesh, holds the Union Health portfolio, which makes the state a particularly charged theatre for this rivalry. Sukhu's framing — 'their tender, their rate contract, their responsibility' — is both a legal defence and a political one, designed to turn an audit question back toward the opposition's most prominent Himachali face.
Whether the Union Health Ministry responds, or whether a formal inquiry surfaces around either procurement, will determine how far this sparring travels beyond a social media exchange.