Congress crosses a line dragging cricket into religious politics
Synopsis
Key Takeaways
Congress MP Imran Masood's allegation of religious discrimination against pacer Mohammed Siraj over his exclusion from the playing XI in the first Test against New Zealand has drawn sharp criticism, with critics arguing it reflects a pattern of the grand old party overstepping the bounds of political decorum. While selectors and cricket analysts point to form and tactical considerations as the basis for team selection, the remark has reignited a broader debate about the Congress's political posture ahead of crucial state elections.
The Masood Remark and Its Context
Imran Masood, a Congress MP considered close to party leader Rahul Gandhi, alleged without substantiation that Siraj's non-selection was driven by religious bias. No evidence was cited, and several party leaders declined to endorse the claim — yet the Congress leadership has, as of 22 November 2026, neither condemned the remark nor issued a reprimand.
Critics note this silence is consistent with the party's handling of an earlier controversy involving Masood, who during the 2014 general election campaign threatened to 'chop' then-BJP prime ministerial candidate Narendra Modi 'into pieces.' Though Rahul Gandhi reportedly disapproved privately, he nonetheless shared a rally stage with Masood at the time. Masood has since risen through party ranks to become one of its most vocal voices.
A Broader Pattern of Contested Remarks
The Masood statement did not emerge in isolation. It coincided with a period of heightened political controversy within the Congress. During his recent US visit, Rahul Gandhi reportedly claimed India was heading toward 'an economic disaster' and described the country as a 'side player' in international affairs — remarks the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) characterised as damaging to India's standing abroad.
Gandhi also drew comparisons between India and Pakistan during the visit, reportedly praising Islamabad's role in facilitating negotiations over the US-Iran conflict. The BJP labelled him a 'Pakistan fan boy' in response.
Earlier, at the 'Bharat Summit 2026' investor conference in Hyderabad on 14 November, Gandhi stated that India was 'no longer functioning as a democracy' and that the democratic system had been 'destroyed in 2014.' He was photographed clapping as Italian politician Giacomo Filibeck raised 'vote chori' slogans — a moment critics described as celebrating foreign criticism of India's electoral institutions at a business forum.
Kharge's Remarks Add to the Controversy
Congress president Mallikarjun Kharge added to the party's string of contested statements in October, when at an event in Patna, Bihar, he called Prime Minister Modi a 'habitual liar' and responded to an audience member with the phrase 'Modi ka baap bhi jayega.' The remarks triggered a fresh political row, with the BJP demanding an apology.
Notably, this is not the first time senior Congress leadership has invited criticism over remarks made outside the country. In March 2023, during an event in London, Gandhi was reported to have said that 'the so-called defenders of democracy, which are the US and European countries, seem to just be oblivious that a huge chunk of the democratic model has come undone,' adding that 'it is not just an Indian battle.' The BJP cited those remarks then as an attempt to internationalise domestic political disputes.
Cricket, Religion, and Electoral Arithmetic
Analysts observing the pattern argue that Masood's cricket remark is best understood through the lens of upcoming Assembly elections across seven states, with Uttar Pradesh as a particular focus. According to the 2011 Census, Muslims constitute over 19 per cent of Uttar Pradesh's population — a constituency that multiple parties seek to mobilise.
The Indian cricket team, by contrast, has historically stood apart from communal narratives. Players such as Syed Kirmani, Sunil Gavaskar, M.S. Dhoni, and Mohammed Shami have commanded universal support regardless of their backgrounds, their identities subsumed within the shared pride of wearing the Indian cap. Critics argue that introducing a religious lens into team selection debates risks undermining that rare space of national unity.
What Comes Next
With assembly elections in multiple states drawing closer, political observers expect the intensity of such exchanges to increase. The Congress has not indicated whether it will issue any formal clarification on Masood's remarks. For the BJP, each such statement provides fresh ammunition for its counter-narrative on what it describes as 'vote bank politics.' Whether the controversy translates into electoral consequences — or simply adds to the noise of an already combative political season — remains to be seen.