Did Kharge Really Get Denied the CM Role in 1999?

Click to start listening
Did Kharge Really Get Denied the CM Role in 1999?

Synopsis

In a controversial statement, Congress President Mallikarjun Kharge claims he was unjustly denied the Chief Minister's position in Karnataka in 1999. This has spurred a heated political discourse, with the BJP alleging that the Gandhi family has historically impeded Dalit leaders' progress. Dive into the implications of this assertion and its ramifications for Karnataka's political landscape.

Key Takeaways

  • Mallikarjun Kharge claims he was unjustly denied the CM post in 1999.
  • The BJP alleges the Gandhi family obstructs Dalit leaders.
  • Political dynamics in Karnataka are under scrutiny.
  • S.M. Krishna's brief rise to power raises questions of loyalty.
  • The conversation highlights ongoing issues of representation.

Bengaluru, July 28 (NationPress) Congress President Mallikarjun Kharge recently stirred up a significant controversy by stating that he was unfairly denied the Chief Minister's position in Karnataka back in 1999, despite his diligent efforts. This assertion has ignited a political discussion throughout the state.

In response to Kharge's comments, the Karnataka BJP accused the Gandhi family of persistently obstructing the advancement of Dalit leaders within the Congress party.

While speaking to a crowd in Vijayapura on Sunday, Kharge remarked, "I also became the CLP (Congress Legislature Party) leader and dedicated my efforts to restore the party's power in Karnataka. Eventually, our government was formed, but S.M. Krishna, who had risen in the party only four months earlier, was appointed as Chief Minister."

Reacting to Kharge's statement, the Leader of the Opposition and seasoned BJP figure R. Ashoka on Monday expressed, "From publicly humiliating former Andhra Pradesh Chief Minister T. Anjaiah on an airport tarmac to expelling Sitaram Kesari from the Congress office like a criminal, and to denying AICC President Mallikarjun Kharge Ji the CM post in 1999 after years of loyalty — every time a Dalit rises in the Congress party, the Gandhi family ensures their downfall."

"Now, Rahul Gandhi, the current Leader of the Opposition, lectures the nation on 'NYAY' (justice). Is this your version of NYAY, Mr. Rahul Gandhi? Will you start by carrying out a Dalit census within your own party leadership? Or are Dalits merely instruments for election speeches, not for genuine empowerment?" Ashoka questioned.

"The reality is, the Congress High Command has always favored tokenism over true transformation — in euphemism, not empowerment," Ashoka charged.

Kharge had previously stated, "As CLP leader, my efforts were focused on bringing the party to power and ensuring a Congress-led government was established in the state. The party did achieve that goal, but subsequently, the late S.M. Krishna — who had just become KPCC President four months prior — was made Chief Minister. All our efforts seemed in vain."

"I felt disheartened. We worked for five years, yet someone who had been with the party for merely four months was elevated to the CM's position. There have been numerous such instances, but it doesn't seem appropriate to discuss everything on the same day," Kharge added.

S.M. Krishna held the Chief Minister position in Karnataka from 1999 to 2004, while Kharge served as a Minister under him.

Before this, Kharge led the Congress as the Leader of the Opposition in the Assembly.

Point of View

It is essential to approach this contentious issue with neutrality. Kharge's claims and the BJP's rebuttals highlight the complex dynamics of leadership and representation in Indian politics. This incident reflects broader themes of empowerment and the ongoing struggle for equality within political ranks, particularly for Dalit leaders.
NationPress
30/07/2025

Frequently Asked Questions

What did Mallikarjun Kharge claim about the CM position?
Mallikarjun Kharge claimed that he was denied the Chief Minister's position in Karnataka in 1999 despite his contributions and hard work.
What was the BJP's response to Kharge's statement?
The BJP accused the Gandhi family of consistently blocking Dalit leaders' advancement within the Congress party.
Who was appointed as Chief Minister in 1999?
S.M. Krishna was appointed as Chief Minister in 1999, just four months after taking on the role of KPCC President.
What are the implications of Kharge's remarks?
Kharge's remarks have ignited a political debate about leadership dynamics and the representation of Dalit leaders within major political parties.
How long did S.M. Krishna serve as Chief Minister?
S.M. Krishna served as Chief Minister of Karnataka from 1999 to 2004.