NDA leaders slam Rahul Gandhi over 'dead economy' remarks at Columbia University
Synopsis
Key Takeaways
Congress leader and Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha, Rahul Gandhi, came under sharp attack from National Democratic Alliance (NDA) leaders on Wednesday, 18 November, after he described India's economy as a 'dead economy' and criticised the country's unemployment and education system during a visit to Columbia University in the United States. NDA leaders accused Gandhi of tarnishing India's image on foreign soil and acting in the interests of forces hostile to the country.
Key Accusations Against Gandhi
Telangana BJP leader T.R. Srinivas was among the first to respond, alleging that Gandhi had embarked on what he called a 'yatra of defaming and demeaning India on foreign shores.' Srinivas questioned whose interests Gandhi was serving by making such remarks at a foreign university.
'Rahul Gandhi started his yatra of defaming and demeaning India on foreign shores. At Columbia University, he was talking about a 'dead economy'. He was talking about an economic disaster. He was talking about democracy having been killed, claiming the BJP is this, the RSS is that, and whatnot. Rahul Gandhi, my simple question to you is: In whose lap are you sitting at Columbia University, talking like this? Which agenda do you want to forward?' Srinivas said.
Srinivas also attempted to draw a historical link between the Congress and the perceived decline of India's education system, citing the year 1967, when Gandhi's grandmother and late Prime Minister Indira Gandhi was reportedly in an alliance with the Communists. He argued that the roots of India's educational challenges lay in that period.
Shiv Sena and Economic Counterarguments
Shiv Sena leader Shaina NC alleged that certain political leaders visited Columbia University with the purpose of insulting Indians, and claimed their political careers were defined solely by opposition to Prime Minister Narendra Modi. She pointed to reports from the International Monetary Fund (IMF) and the World Bank as evidence of India being among the world's fastest-growing economies.
Contrasting the current government's economic record with that of the previous United Progressive Alliance (UPA) administration, NC referenced the 2G spectrum allocation controversy, the coal allocation controversy, the Commonwealth Games controversy, and high inflation under UPA rule. She noted that Goods and Services Tax (GST) collections had reached record levels under the current dispensation.
'Some parties just want to defame the government, defame Bharat, and engage in politics of hatred. The moment you take a positive approach, you will realise where India has reached to become a Viksit Bharat,' she said.
UP Deputy CM and Bihar Minister Weigh In
Uttar Pradesh Deputy Chief Minister Keshav Prasad Maurya broadened the criticism beyond Gandhi, alleging that multiple Opposition leaders — including Akhilesh Yadav, Tejashwi Yadav, and Mamata Banerjee — were acting at the behest of anti-India international forces.
'Be it Rahul Gandhi, Akhilesh Yadav, Tejashwi Yadav, or Mamata Banerjee — all of them are acting at the behest of anti-India international forces and doing many things that no patriot should do. Congress is an old political party, and its 'Yuvraj' Rahul Gandhi continuously engages in such acts. We strongly condemn this, and wherever elections are held, the public will respond to them democratically using their constitutional rights,' Maurya said.
Bihar Minister Ram Kripal Yadav questioned whether Gandhi's remarks served his own party's interests, arguing that criticising one's country on an international platform was unbecoming. 'Rahul Gandhi has ruined the Congress and will continue to do so. Tell me, would anyone complain about their own country abroad? A patriot would never do that. You are bringing disrepute to the country on an international platform. The people of the country will never forgive you,' he said.
GDP Data Cited in Rebuttal
BJP Jharkhand leader Pratul Shah Deo directly challenged Gandhi's characterisation of the economy as 'dead', citing a World Bank report that claimed India's real GDP growth stood at 7.8 per cent, with nominal growth above 9 per cent. Deo questioned why Gandhi appeared to have a specific connection with Columbia, also referencing earlier remarks Gandhi had reportedly made about the university at the launch of Sonia Gandhi's book.
This episode follows a pattern of NDA leaders responding forcefully each time Gandhi makes critical remarks about India before international audiences — a dynamic that has played out repeatedly over the past two years as the Congress leader has travelled abroad and addressed forums at foreign universities. With state elections on the horizon, the political temperature around such remarks is unlikely to cool soon.