Ashish Shelar dares Rahul Gandhi to explain Congress' stand on electoral roll SIR
Synopsis
Key Takeaways
Maharashtra Cultural Affairs Minister and senior Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) leader Ashish Shelar on Tuesday, 17 November 2026, challenged Leader of Opposition in Lok Sabha Rahul Gandhi to publicly explain the Congress party's position on the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls, accusing the opposition of manufacturing confusion and suspicion around a process that Congress itself oversaw multiple times when in power.
Shelar's Central Charge
Minister Shelar alleged that Congress and Rahul Gandhi are 'deliberately attempting to create an atmosphere of doubt and suspicion' around the SIR exercise, even as the party has filed a petition in the Supreme Court challenging the process. He questioned why Congress chose to approach the courts rather than raise its objections on the floor of Parliament, where Gandhi holds the constitutionally significant position of Leader of the Opposition.
'While filing a petition in the Supreme Court is their right, why have they not raised these very questions in the Parliament?' Shelar said, addressing reporters in Mumbai.
The 12-Times Argument
Central to Shelar's counter-offensive is a historical challenge: he claimed that the SIR process was conducted 12 times during Congress-led governments, yet no objections were raised at that time. 'During its tenure in power, the Congress oversaw the SIR process not once or twice, but 12 times. Why did it not raise the questions and suggestions being put forward today back then? If the process was acceptable then, how has the very same process suddenly become unacceptable now?' he asked.
He further pressed Congress to disclose how many times its own Booth Level Officers (BLOs) had raised demands, filed complaints, or submitted suggestions about the SIR process at various levels of the election machinery — and how many voters its Booth Level Agent-2 (BLA-2) representatives had informed about their appeal rights.
Constitutional and Appointment Questions
Shelar broadened his attack to include Congress's historical record on electoral laws and institutional appointments. He asked Gandhi to clarify how many amendments Congress made to the Representation of the People Act and the Indian Constitution's voter-eligibility provisions during its years in government. He also questioned the process by which Chief Election Commissioners were appointed under Congress-led administrations, alleging those appointments were made through Cabinet decisions or on the government's recommendations — without the multi-member committee that Congress now appears to advocate.
Allegation of Protecting Ineligible Voters
In a pointed accusation, Shelar alleged that by opposing the SIR, Congress and Gandhi were effectively working to keep the names of approximately three crore illegal or ineligible voters on the electoral rolls. He asked directly whether Congress's position was that non-Indian citizens and ineligible voters should not have their names removed. 'Creating unnecessary confusion among the public is equally unjustified,' he said, while acknowledging that the legal dispute would be settled in court.
Six Questions, A Public Demand
Shelar concluded by challenging Rahul Gandhi and Congress leaders in Maharashtra to answer the six specific questions he raised — mirroring the 39 questions Congress had reportedly put to the Election Commission about the SIR process. 'The legal battle will be fought in court, but questions raised by the people must be answered before the people,' he asserted. The escalating war of words reflects deepening tensions ahead of what analysts expect to be a contentious electoral roll revision cycle.