Ashwin: Cummins discredited Khawaja as a person, not his Sandpapergate account
Synopsis
Key Takeaways
Former India off-spinner Ravichandran Ashwin has weighed in on the reignited Sandpapergate controversy, saying he was genuinely shocked when Australian captain Pat Cummins chose to discredit Usman Khawaja as an individual rather than simply contest the specifics of his claims. Ashwin made the remarks on JioStar during a programme titled 'Sandpapergate: The Unsettled Debate' on 17 November 2026.
What Khawaja Claimed
The controversy resurfaced after Usman Khawaja made explosive allegations in his autobiography, Sabr, asserting that the entire Australian team was aware of sandpaper being used to tamper with the cricket ball during the 2018 Cape Town Test against South Africa. Khawaja went further, claiming the same practice had been employed in the preceding Test in Port Elizabeth. The original scandal had already cost Steve Smith and David Warner year-long bans and triggered one of cricket's deepest institutional crises.
Cummins Hits Back, Calls Claims 'Complete and Utter Nonsense'
Pat Cummins, now Australia's Test captain, held a 70-minute media briefing in response to Khawaja's book, flatly rejecting the allegations as 'complete and utter nonsense.' The length and tone of the press conference drew as much attention as its content, with observers noting the unusual step of a sitting captain dedicating over an hour to rebutting a teammate's memoir.
Ashwin's Reaction: Discrediting the Man, Not the Account
Ashwin drew a sharp distinction between challenging facts and attacking credibility. 'Firstly, when Usman Khawaja has mentioned certain things in his book, those are his accounts of the story and we need to respect that. But what happened at Pat Cummins's press conference is that he didn't discredit Usman Khawaja's account of the story; he discredited the man himself. And that is the problem for me,' Ashwin said.
He vouched personally for Khawaja's character, noting their time playing alongside each other. 'I know Usman Khawaja; I've played a lot of cricket with him, not on a personal front. He is a man of high integrity and a really honest and up-and-straightforward person,' Ashwin added.
Ashwin Questions Cummins' Position in 2018 Leadership Group
Ashwin also raised a pointed contextual argument: that Cummins was only on his third tour during the 2018 South Africa series and was unlikely to have been part of the inner leadership circle. 'He couldn't have been a part of the leadership group. Steve Smith, David Warner and maybe Tim Paine were, if I'm not wrong,' Ashwin said. He suggested Cummins could simply have acknowledged limited awareness rather than mounting a full-frontal challenge to Khawaja's integrity. 'I genuinely thought that this conversation would have centred around saying, "I wasn't aware of what exactly was happening. I wasn't a part of the leadership group." It was very surprising for me that Pat Cummins had to come to the press conference and discredit the person himself. That was a little bit of a shock to me, watching from afar,' he added.
Why This Matters for Australian Cricket
The Sandpapergate episode of 2018 remains the most damaging scandal in modern Australian cricket history, triggering a wholesale review of team culture. Khawaja's memoir re-opens questions that Cricket Australia had effectively considered closed, and Cummins' forceful rebuttal — rather than a measured acknowledgement — risks extending the controversy. Notably, this is the first time a current Australian captain has publicly countered a teammate's first-hand account of the incident. How Cricket Australia responds, and whether Khawaja chooses to elaborate further, will determine how deep this new chapter of the saga runs.