Ashwin on Sandpapergate: 'Australian dressing room is not crackless'
Synopsis
Key Takeaways
Former India spinner Ravichandran Ashwin has weighed in on the reignited Sandpapergate controversy, saying the sharply contrasting statements from current and former Australian players reveal that cracks in the Australian dressing room — present in 2018 — have not fully healed even now. Ashwin made the remarks on Star Sports' programme Sandpapergate: the unsettled debate.
What Khawaja Claimed
The debate was reignited after former Australian opener Usman Khawaja alleged in his autobiography, Sabr, that the entire Australian team was aware of the sandpaper being used on the ball during the 2018 Cape Town Test against South Africa, and that the same practice had occurred in the previous Test in Port Elizabeth. Only three players — then-captain Steve Smith, opener David Warner, and Cameron Bancroft, who was seen on camera applying the sandpaper — were sanctioned at the time.
The Divided Voices Inside Australian Cricket
Khawaja's account has since split the Australian camp. Warner backed Khawaja's version, while current Australian captain Pat Cummins flatly rejected the claims, calling them 'complete and utter nonsense'. Ashwin noted the stark divergence. 'Someone like Pat Cummins, who I really admire as a cricketer, is the captain of Australia... has come out and called what Usman Khawaja has said as baseless, as nonsense, and as something that does not have proof. And now, that is a chalk-and-cheese statement, where he has actually gone on to say, contrasting opinions to what Khawaja has given,' Ashwin observed. He added that Warner has 'continued on his own thread of saying what he believes is right.'
Ashwin: Khawaja Is Demanding Collective Accountability
According to Ashwin, the core message of Khawaja's book is a call for shared responsibility. 'What's happened at the end of this book being written is that Usman Khawaja, while he has said all those statements, he's given his story, (he) has made only one thing very clear. And that's crystal clear, which is, he is asking for collective accountability. He is saying, which is pretty accurate in this case, that it was not only three people that knew about it; there were more,' Ashwin said.
Cricket Australia's Stance and Ashwin's Reading
Ashwin said he approved of Cricket Australia's decision not to reopen the investigation. 'I love what the CEO of Cricket Australia has done. He's come out and said, 'We're not going to reopen the case,' which I think is the right way to do,' he said. However, he stressed that the conflicting public statements were themselves revealing. 'One thing is very crystal clear in this, Anand, which is there were cracks in the Australian dressing room in the past in terms of views and opinions on this. And I don't think it is crackless even now. And that would be the more concerning part for me,' Ashwin added.
Why This Matters for Australian Cricket
With Australia preparing for a busy international season, the internal dissonance over one of the sport's most controversial episodes adds an uncomfortable backdrop to Cummins' leadership. The 2018 Sandpapergate scandal triggered lifetime bans that were later reduced, led to a sweeping cultural review of Australian cricket, and reshaped the careers of Smith, Warner, and Bancroft. That its fallout still generates contradictory testimonies from the players who were there suggests the full story, as Ashwin implies, may never be entirely settled.