Chappell: Sandpapergate cover-up cost CA more than the act itself
Synopsis
Key Takeaways
Former Australia captain Greg Chappell has charged Cricket Australia (CA) with paying a prolonged institutional price for a rushed and incomplete investigation into the 2018 ball-tampering scandal at Newlands, Cape Town, arguing that suppressing uncomfortable truths only delays — never prevents — their eventual reckoning.
Chappell's remarks, published in his column for The Sydney Morning Herald on Saturday, 20 November, arrive in the wake of Cameron Bancroft's explosive claim that the entire Australia squad was aware of the plan to tamper with the ball during the Cape Town Test against South Africa. Bancroft also admitted he withheld details when first questioned by CA. Fast bowler Chadd Sayers and others have since corroborated that account; Australia's current Test captain Pat Cummins and the other bowlers have denied any foreknowledge.
Chappell's Watergate Warning
'When Watergate brought down a presidency, the lesson was the same — the cover-up does more damage than the original offence. Hiding uncomfortable truths doesn't make them go away,' Chappell wrote. 'They find their own way out, and the only way to protect an institution is to face them honestly when they first appear. Cricket Australia is learning that in public, and it's painful to watch.'
The former captain admitted he found it hard to accept that only three players — Bancroft, Steve Smith, and David Warner — were the sole architects and custodians of the plan. 'I wasn't there and can't prove otherwise, but I find it difficult to believe that only three men were aware. What I can say is that the process that should have settled this eight years ago didn't, and we're all paying for it now,' he said.
Bancroft's Burden and CA's Investigation Shortcomings
Chappell reserved particular sympathy for Bancroft, noting that unlike Smith and Warner — both of whom rebuilt reputations with run-scoring — Bancroft lacked the same platform for redemption. 'Bancroft has carried a heavy load for a long time. Steve Smith and David Warner had the talent to rebuild their reputations with runs. Bancroft didn't get that chance, and he's had to wear the stigma mostly alone, branded by many as the man behind a plan that made no sense,' he wrote.
He also questioned why then-media manager Kate Hutchison's advice on crisis management was set aside. 'She also gave sensible advice on how to handle the crisis once the cameras caught the attempt. Who brushed her aside, and why? Was it the senior players who thought they knew better? We should know who made that call, and why,' Chappell wrote. With hindsight, he argued, a more thorough interview of the full playing group at the time would have resolved the matter definitively.
Why It Took Eight Years to Surface
Chappell pointed to cricket's unwritten dressing-room code — and players' fear for their places — as the principal reasons it took so long for wider knowledge to be acknowledged. He defended Usman Khawaja, whose memoir Sabr reopened the debate. 'Why did it take eight years for any of this to come out? Anyone who has played Test cricket knows the answer. You don't speak up against your own side, you worry about your place in the team, and there's an unwritten code that what happens in the dressing room stays there,' he wrote, adding that the silence was understandable but not excusable.
He argued that autobiographies were a legitimate outlet when in-career channels were unavailable, and called for a formal, confidential mechanism for players and staff to raise concerns 'with someone outside the chain of command, without it costing him his place.'
Cummins Leadership Question and Travis Head as Successor
On the growing calls for Cummins to resign as Test captain, Chappell urged restraint, warning against repeating the hasty punishments of 2018. 'The mistake of 2018 was punishing people before the facts were known, and I don't want to see it repeated. Believing others knew isn't the same as proving it. No man should lose his job based on a disputed account, no matter which side it comes from,' he said.
He acknowledged Cummins carried responsibility for team culture, but drew a distinction between cultural accountability and personal culpability for something he may not have known about at the time. Australia's next Test assignment is against New Zealand in Perth starting 9 December, and Chappell stressed the squad needed stability rather than further disruption.
Should a change prove necessary, Chappell named Travis Head as the right successor. Head made his Test debut in October 2018 — months after Newlands — leaving him untouched by the affair. South Australia appointed him captain at 21, and he was named co-vice-captain of the national side in 2023. 'He's also delivered in the biggest games, with a hundred in the 2023 World Test Championship final and another in that year's World Cup final. A new captain from outside the 2018 group would give the team a fresh start while the old argument settles elsewhere,' Chappell concluded.
With a formal inquiry now expected, the question is whether CA will draw the full conclusions that eluded the original investigation — or once again leave the dressing-room code intact at the cost of institutional credibility.