Delhi HC dismisses doctor's plea to de-index Assam bail order from Google

Share:
Audio Loading voice…
Delhi HC dismisses doctor's plea to de-index Assam bail order from Google

Synopsis

A Delhi High Court ruling has drawn a firm jurisdictional boundary on 'right to be forgotten' cases involving digitised judicial records — holding that online accessibility of a Gauhati HC bail order in Delhi does not give Delhi courts the power to order its removal from Google. The verdict has wide implications for similar petitions filed in courts far from where the original proceedings occurred.

Key Takeaways

The Delhi High Court dismissed a doctor's petition on 20 November 2026 seeking removal of a 2019 Gauhati HC bail order from Google and Indian Kanoon search results.
Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma ruled that the petitioner's residence in Delhi and the online accessibility of the record in Delhi cannot confer territorial jurisdiction on the Delhi HC.
The FIR , arrest, bail proceedings, chargesheet and discharge all took place in Assam , making the Gauhati High Court the appropriate forum.
The court warned that allowing internet accessibility to determine jurisdiction would render Article 226(2) of the Constitution meaningless and encourage forum shopping .
The petitioner, discharged from the criminal case on 8 January 2021 , remains free to approach the Gauhati High Court; the Delhi HC made no ruling on the merits of his privacy claim.

The Delhi High Court on 20 November 2026 dismissed a practising doctor's petition seeking directions to Google and legal database Indian Kanoon to remove a 2019 bail order from name-based online search results, ruling that his mere residence in Delhi or the online accessibility of a judicial record within the national capital cannot confer territorial jurisdiction on the court.

Background: The Doctor's Grievance

The petitioner, a practising doctor, had approached the Delhi High Court to de-index a bail order passed by the Gauhati High Court on 27 September 2019 from name-based search results on Google and Indian Kanoon. He also sought the disabling of name-based search functionality with respect to that judicial record.

He argued that although a Judicial Magistrate in Assam had discharged him from the underlying criminal case on 8 January 2021 — an order that had attained finality — the bail order continued to surface when his name was searched online, adversely affecting his reputation and professional standing. He invoked the right to informational privacy under Article 21 of the Constitution as the basis for his claim.

What the Court Ruled

A single-judge Bench of Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma upheld a preliminary objection raised by the respondents on territorial jurisdiction. The court observed that the FIR, arrest, bail proceedings, chargesheet, and eventual discharge had all occurred in Assam, making the Gauhati High Court the appropriate forum.

'The judicial record in question is the record of the High Court of Gauhati, and the record of the underlying criminal proceedings, which would be germane to determine the petitioner's entitlement to the relief sought, is also situated in Assam,' the judgment noted.

Justice Sharma explicitly rejected the argument that the online accessibility of the bail order via Google and Indian Kanoon in Delhi constituted a part of the cause of action, observing that digitised judicial records are accessible across the country and even globally.

The Forum Shopping Warning

'If the mere accessibility of a digitised judicial record at a particular place were to be treated as an integral part of the cause of action, every High Court in the country would possess the jurisdiction to entertain a petition seeking de-indexing of a judicial record of any other Court,' the judge said. The court cautioned that accepting such an interpretation would render the territorial jurisdiction requirement under Article 226(2) of the Constitution meaningless and encourage forum shopping.

Invoking the doctrine of forum conveniens, the Delhi High Court further held that any direction regulating the access or searchability of a record of the Gauhati High Court would be most appropriately examined by that court itself. Entertaining the petition in Delhi, the court noted, could result in overlapping or conflicting directions from two different High Courts on the same judicial record.

What Happens Next

The Delhi High Court dismissed the petition along with all pending applications for want of territorial jurisdiction, while expressly leaving open the petitioner's right to approach the Gauhati High Court for the same relief. The court clarified that its observations carry no opinion on the merits of the doctor's de-indexing claim, keeping his substantive rights to informational privacy intact for adjudication by the appropriate forum.

The ruling is likely to serve as a significant precedent for similar right-to-be-forgotten petitions filed in courts outside the jurisdiction where the original proceedings were conducted — a question of growing relevance as digitised judicial records become universally searchable.

Point of View

The temptation to file in a convenient High Court — rather than the one that passed the original order — will grow. Justice Sharma's reasoning is doctrinally sound: allowing internet accessibility to substitute for a genuine cause of action would effectively grant every High Court in the country pan-India jurisdiction over every other court's records. The deeper question the judgment leaves open is whether India needs a uniform, centralised mechanism for de-indexing judicial records — one that does not require litigants to navigate jurisdictional hurdles that can delay or deny substantive relief under Article 21.
NationPress
20 Nov 2026

Frequently Asked Questions

Why did the Delhi High Court dismiss the doctor's petition?
The Delhi High Court dismissed the petition because it lacked territorial jurisdiction. The court held that the doctor's residence in Delhi and the online accessibility of the Gauhati HC bail order in Delhi do not constitute a material part of the cause of action, as the FIR, arrest, bail proceedings, chargesheet and discharge all occurred in Assam.
What was the doctor seeking and why?
The doctor sought directions to Google and Indian Kanoon to de-index a bail order passed by the Gauhati High Court on 27 September 2019 from name-based search results. He argued the order harmed his reputation and professional standing even after he was discharged from the criminal case in January 2021, invoking the right to informational privacy under Article 21 of the Constitution.
Which court should the doctor now approach?
The Delhi High Court expressly left open the petitioner's right to approach the Gauhati High Court for the same relief. The court made no ruling on the merits of his de-indexing claim, so his substantive rights remain intact for adjudication by the appropriate forum.
Why did the court reject the argument that internet accessibility creates jurisdiction?
Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma held that digitised judicial records are accessible across the country and even globally. Treating online accessibility at any location as part of the cause of action would allow every High Court in India to exercise jurisdiction over any other court's records — rendering the territorial requirement under Article 226(2) of the Constitution meaningless and enabling forum shopping.
What is the broader significance of this ruling for right-to-be-forgotten cases in India?
The judgment sets a significant precedent that petitions seeking de-indexing of judicial records must be filed before the court whose record is in question, not in a court chosen for geographic convenience. It is expected to influence how similar privacy-linked de-indexing petitions are filed across India as digitised court records become universally searchable.
Nation Press
The Trail

Connected Dots

Tracing the thread behind this story — newest first.

8 Dots
  1. Latest 3 months ago
  2. 4 months ago
  3. 6 months ago
  4. 7 months ago
  5. 7 months ago
  6. 1 year ago
  7. 1 year ago
  8. 1 year ago
Google Prefer NP
On Google