Hiriyur bypoll: Kumaraswamy says BJP-JD(S) alliance intact amid seat row
Synopsis
Key Takeaways
Political tensions within Karnataka's National Democratic Alliance (NDA) are simmering ahead of the Hiriyur Assembly constituency bypoll, with alliance partners Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) and Janata Dal (Secular) (JD(S)) both staking claim to the seat — even before the Election Commission of India (ECI) has formally announced the election schedule.
Kumaraswamy Downplays Differences
Union Minister for Heavy Industries and Steel H.D. Kumaraswamy, speaking to reporters on Monday at the pilgrimage centre of Kollur in Udupi district, sought to play down reports of a rift. He said JD(S) remained 'open-minded' about the candidate decision but was firm that the broader alliance showed no signs of fracture.
'Our party is open-minded about the decision on fielding a candidate. We are ready. There is no difference of opinion regarding the continuation of the alliance,' Kumaraswamy said.
He acknowledged that the BJP had expressed its desire to contest the Hiriyur seat but urged the party's leaders to weigh the constituency's political history before arriving at a decision. He pointed out that electoral contests in Hiriyur had historically been between the Janata Dal and the Indian National Congress (Congress), with the BJP holding no significant foothold there before 2013.
The Historical Stakes in Hiriyur
Kumaraswamy recalled that in the 2013 Assembly election, former minister Krishnappa was denied a Congress ticket at the last moment and was subsequently fielded by JD(S). Despite campaigning for only 15 days, Krishnappa polled more than 70,000 votes and lost by a narrow margin of just 1,205 votes. He attributed the defeat partly to the confusion over the ticket.
Kumaraswamy also noted that Manjunath, a multi-term MLA and former minister, had previously represented the party in the constituency — reinforcing JD(S)'s claim to historical ownership of the seat.
BJP's Rival Claim
R. Ashoka, Leader of Opposition in the Karnataka Legislative Assembly, struck a sharply different tone on Sunday. He said the state BJP had resolved that Hiriyur should be allocated to its party, and expressed confidence that the BJP's central leadership would prevail upon JD(S) to concede the seat.
'We have decided that the seat should go to our party. I will also speak to Kumaraswamy. Ultimately, I am confident that our central leaders will convince them and ensure the seat is given to the BJP,' Ashoka said.
Ashoka also referenced reports suggesting that roughly 80 per cent of BJP leaders in the state favoured fielding their own candidate — a figure Kumaraswamy acknowledged but said had not been formally placed before him.
Why the Bypoll Was Called
The bypoll has been necessitated by the death of former minister D. Sudhakar, who had represented Hiriyur in Chitradurga district. Sudhakar was reportedly close to Karnataka Chief Minister D.K. Shivakumar, who during a recent visit to the region hinted that the Congress ticket could go to Sudhakar's son.
The BJP won the Hiriyur seat in the 2018 Assembly elections by fielding Poornima Krishnappa, a result it cites as evidence of its electoral viability in the constituency. This precedent underpins the party's insistence on contesting the upcoming bypoll.
What This Means for the NDA Alliance in Karnataka
The seat-sharing dispute, though publicly minimised by both sides, is widely seen as a stress test for the BJP-JD(S) understanding that was cemented during the 2024 Lok Sabha elections under the direction of the Prime Minister and the national leadership. Kumaraswamy was emphatic that the alliance remained a priority: 'Such a proposal has neither come before me nor been discussed with me. Our priority is to ensure that there are no differences in the NDA alliance.'
Notably, reports of some BJP leaders pushing to contest Zilla Panchayat and Taluk Panchayat elections independently add another layer of pressure on the coalition. With the ECI yet to announce the bypoll schedule, both parties appear to be jostling for position before formal negotiations begin in earnest.