Is Pakistan Moving Towards Direct Military Rule Under Munir's Command?

Click to start listening
Is Pakistan Moving Towards Direct Military Rule Under Munir's Command?

Synopsis

As Field Marshal Asim Munir ascends to the Chief of Defence Forces in Pakistan, the nation teeters on the brink of direct military control. This article explores the implications of this pivotal moment in Pakistan's political landscape, echoing historical patterns of military dominance.

Key Takeaways

  • Field Marshal Asim Munir consolidates military power in Pakistan.
  • The 27th Constitutional Amendment grants him lifelong immunity.
  • Historical patterns show a trend towards military rule.
  • Political repression against PTI under Munir's leadership.
  • Implications for democracy remain uncertain.

Washington, Nov 27 (NationPress) Field Marshal Asim Munir is poised to solidify his position as the most influential figure in Pakistan following his appointment as the Chief of Defence Forces (CDF) under the 27th Constitutional Amendment, indicating a shift towards direct military governance, a report reveals.

The establishment of the CDF role came after the passage of a constitutional amendment by Pakistan's parliament in November, placing Munir in command of the nation's navy and air forces, along with providing him with lifelong legal immunity.

A report from The Christian Science Monitor notes, "While the title is novel, it evokes a sense of history repeating. Since its independence in 1947, Pakistan has alternated between civilian and military governance. Direct military rule has occurred for 33 of the nation's 78 years, while the military has influenced politics from behind the scenes for the remaining 45 years, manipulating politicians and governments."

The report continues, "Under Field Marshal Munir's command, the army has influenced elections and initiated a severe crackdown on Pakistan’s leading political party, Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI), whose head, former Prime Minister Imran Khan, is currently imprisoned. Following earlier conflicts with India, the army and its allies—often referred to as 'the establishment'—have seen a surge in popularity. This amendment brings Pakistan closer to direct military governance. As historian Ayesha Jalal puts it, 'We are witnessing a military that has always been strong becoming even more powerful.'"

The report highlights that historians and analysts are debating how the military cemented such a lasting influence in Pakistani politics, tracing back to 1852. After the British partitioned the subcontinent in 1947, Punjab predominantly joined Pakistan. The military soon overshadowed the political class, largely made up of migrants from what is now India.

The Pakistani army appeared invulnerable under the last military ruler Pervez Musharraf until two rivals united to prevent military intervention in politics. Following Musharraf's regime, the Pakistan Muslim League (PMLN) and Pakistan People’s Party (PPP) agreed not to be used as political pawns in a restored democracy, as reported by The Christian Science Monitor.

The 2013 general election marked Pakistan's first peaceful transition of power between elected civilian administrations. In response to this challenge, the military began to support Imran Khan as an alternative leader, facilitating his rise to power during the same election. After tensions escalated between Khan and the military, the latter orchestrated the removal of the PTI founder via a no-confidence vote in 2022.

Currently, according to the report, Field Marshal Munir is granted an additional five years in authority, along with control over Pakistan's nuclear arsenal and lifelong immunity from prosecution due to the new 27th amendment.

Point of View

I believe that the rise of military influence in Pakistan, particularly under Field Marshal Munir, warrants close scrutiny. The implications of this shift could have profound consequences for democracy and governance in the country. It is essential that we remain vigilant and prioritize the nation's democratic values while navigating this complex political landscape.
NationPress
27/11/2025

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the significance of the 27th Constitutional Amendment?
The 27th Constitutional Amendment created the position of Chief of Defence Forces in Pakistan, granting Field Marshal Asim Munir control over the military and lifelong immunity from legal prosecution.
How has the military historically influenced Pakistan's politics?
Since gaining independence in 1947, Pakistan has alternated between civilian and military rule, with the military directly governing for 33 years and influencing political outcomes from behind the scenes for 45 years.
What role does the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) play in the current political landscape?
The PTI, led by former Prime Minister Imran Khan, has faced a brutal crackdown from the military under Field Marshal Munir, especially after Khan's removal through a no-confidence vote in 2022.
What does the future hold for democracy in Pakistan?
With the military's growing power under Munir, the future of democracy in Pakistan is uncertain, as historical patterns suggest a potential decline in civilian governance.
What are the risks of military rule in Pakistan?
Military rule often leads to the suppression of political dissent, curtailment of civil liberties, and instability in governance, hindering the democratic process and citizen rights.
Nation Press