Why is there a Ruckus in the Rajasthan Assembly over CCTVs?
Click to start listening
Synopsis
On September 10, chaos erupted in the Rajasthan Assembly as Congress raised concerns over newly installed surveillance cameras, alleging 'spying' by the state government. Despite assurances from Assembly Speaker Vasudev Devnani about privacy protections, tensions flared, overshadowing crucial discussions and leading to a dramatic session.
Key Takeaways
- The Rajasthan Assembly experienced significant disruption due to protests by Congress MLAs over new surveillance cameras.
- Claims of privacy violations were countered by the Assembly Speaker, emphasizing the technical nature of the upgrades.
- The situation escalated into heated debates, leading to an adjournment of proceedings.
- Constructive dialogue is essential to resolve concerns while maintaining legislative integrity.
Jaipur, Sep 10 (NationPress) The Rajasthan Assembly found itself embroiled in turmoil once again on Wednesday as the dispute regarding the addition of extra surveillance cameras escalated, fueled by the Opposition Congress.
Despite Assembly Speaker Vasudev Devnani clarifying that these cameras do not record audio and do not infringe on privacy, Congress MLAs remained skeptical, rushing into the Well of the House while shouting slogans.
Leader of the Opposition Tika Ram Jully accused the state government of engaging in "spying" through the installation of two new cameras and questioned why he lacked access to the official YouTube feed.
"Initially, you claimed the cameras were upgraded; now you acknowledge that new cameras were installed. Why do these cameras remain operational even after the session is adjourned? Who has control over them, and do they provide YouTube access?" LoP Jully challenged.
The uproar erupted soon after the Question Hour.
State Parliamentary Affairs Minister Jogaram Patel, mocking the Congress MLAs for boycotting previous sessions, outlined the reasons behind their protests.
His comments intensified the situation, resulting in fiery exchanges between the Treasury and Opposition benches.
With the ruckus escalating from both sides, Speaker Devnani chose to adjourn the proceedings until 2 p.m. on Wednesday.
In response to the accusations from Congress MLAs, Speaker Devnani stated that cameras have been a part of the Assembly since its inception.
As part of the 'One Nation, One Application' initiative, technical enhancements were implemented for live streaming on YouTube and for international events like the Commonwealth Parliamentary Association sessions.
Cameras were also installed in the officers' gallery following requests from MLAs to monitor attendance.
"None of the cameras capture audio. This is merely a standard technical upgrade. Claims of spying are unfounded. Cameras exist in Parliament as well. Privacy has neither been compromised nor will it be," the Speaker asserted, calling for cooperation to ensure the House operates smoothly.
Earlier on Wednesday, Congress MLAs had boycotted the Question Hour, brandished posters, and marched from the MLA quarters to the Assembly.
They argued that the new cameras were strategically aimed at monitoring the Opposition benches during private discussions.
This issue overshadowed other important matters, including tributes to children lost in the Jhalawar school tragedy and the passage of two bills on the final day of the Monsoon session.
For two consecutive days, the Zero Hour has been entirely disrupted due to protests from Congress.
Point of View
It is crucial to approach the ongoing controversy in the Rajasthan Assembly with a balanced perspective. The installation of additional cameras raises legitimate concerns regarding privacy, but it is essential to recognize the government's efforts in enhancing transparency and security within the Assembly. Both sides must engage in constructive dialogue to address these issues without undermining democratic processes.
NationPress
10/09/2025
Frequently Asked Questions
What triggered the uproar in the Rajasthan Assembly?
The uproar was triggered by the Opposition Congress's concerns over newly installed surveillance cameras, which they alleged were for 'spying.'
What did the Assembly Speaker say regarding the cameras?
Assembly Speaker Vasudev Devnani clarified that the cameras do not record audio and are part of a technical upgrade aimed at enhancing transparency.
What are the implications of the protests?
The protests have overshadowed other significant legislative matters, highlighting tensions between the government and the Opposition.
