Rajasthan HC upholds Jaipur royal family's ownership of Rajmahal Palace
Synopsis
Key Takeaways
The Rajasthan High Court has dismissed appeals filed by the Rajasthan state government and the Jaipur Development Authority (JDA), upholding a lower court's ruling that recognised the former Jaipur royal family's ownership of the disputed Rajmahal Palace property in Jaipur. The verdict, delivered by Justice Ashok Kumar Jain, brings the long-running property battle closer to resolution in favour of the erstwhile royals.
Background of the Dispute
The case traces its origins to a contested stretch of approximately 120 bighas and 14 biswas of land associated with Rajmahal Palace and Brigadier Maharaja Sawai Bhawani Singh and others. An acquisition process for 65 bighas and 16 biswas of that land was initiated in 1972–73, after which the land was entered in the JDA's name in revenue records. A separate dispute subsequently arose over the remaining 54 bighas and 18 biswas, with the former royal family contesting the JDA's statutory entitlement to that portion.
The case drew heightened public attention during the tenure of IAS officer Shikhar Agrawal as Jaipur Development Commissioner (JDC), when authorities sealed the gates of the luxury Rajmahal Palace Hotel. Notably, both Agrawal and then-IAS officer Mukesh Sharma tendered an apology before the court during hearings in 2016, following which they were exempted from personal appearance.
What the High Court Found
Justice Jain dismissed the appeals challenging the 24 November 2011 judgment of the Additional District and Sessions Judge (ADJ-5), Fast Track Court, Jaipur. The High Court observed that the grounds raised by the state government in its appeal ought to have been presented before the trial court and could not be introduced at the appellate stage.
The court also noted that the government and the JDA failed to provide a satisfactory explanation for the delay in submitting additional documents. Crucially, the court held that revenue records — including 'jamabandi' and 'khasra' entries — do not constitute conclusive proof of ownership, and that merely recording government ownership in such documents does not automatically convert privately held property into government land.
The Role of Covenants and Maps
The High Court emphasised the importance of covenants in determining ownership. Maps submitted during proceedings indicated that the 'Princess House' estate encompassed not just a bungalow but also other structures, surrounding premises, gardens, and additional facilities. The state government and the JDA had argued that the land had been recorded in the government's name since 1958 and that this entry had remained unchallenged for decades. They further contended that the 'Princess House' referenced in the covenant referred only to Bungalow No. 7 in Civil Lines, and that Rajmahal Palace was a separate property not covered by the covenant — an argument the court did not accept.
Titles Retained, Relief Granted
In accordance with an earlier High Court ruling, the titles 'Maharaja', 'Princess', and 'Rajmata' have been retained alongside the names of the respondents in the appeals. The latest order delivers significant relief to the former royal family after years of litigation, though the state government retains the option of approaching a higher forum.