Shashi Tharoor backs Rahul Gandhi on Israel-Palestine, defends Congress stance
Synopsis
Key Takeaways
Congress MP Shashi Tharoor on Sunday, 22 November defended Leader of Opposition Rahul Gandhi's remarks on the Israel-Palestine conflict, asserting that the Congress party supports both Palestine's right to statehood and Israel's right to live in peace and security. Tharoor's remarks came in response to sharp criticism from former Kerala Chief Minister Pinarayi Vijayan, who accused Gandhi of adopting double standards on the conflict.
What Rahul Gandhi Said
Gandhi had made his comments on the Israel-Palestine conflict while speaking at the University of Chicago. He condemned the 7 October Hamas attacks as 'absolutely condemnable' while simultaneously criticising Israel's military response in Gaza as disproportionate. His remarks, which included a defence of India's strategic relationship with Israel and continued defence purchases, drew significant political pushback, particularly from the left.
Tharoor's Defence of Gandhi
Speaking to reporters, Tharoor articulated what he described as Gandhi's balanced position. 'Rahul Gandhi's stand is very clear. He says that the attack of October 7 was absolutely condemnable; it actually killed and hurt innocent civilians. But equally, the Israeli disproportionate response in Gaza has also hurt and killed a lot of civilians; it has affected their homes and livelihoods,' Tharoor said.
The Thiruvananthapuram MP added: 'I don't see anything wrong in what Rahul Gandhi has said. He has made the point very clear, and I don't think that the Indian stand can be very different. We stand with the Palestinians in terms of their rights to have their own state and their own livelihood. We also stand with the Israeli right to live in peace and security.' Tharoor also underlined that neither position endorses the killing of civilians on either side.
Vijayan's Broadside on X
The controversy was ignited by former Kerala Chief Minister Pinarayi Vijayan, who posted a pointed attack on Gandhi via his account on X. 'Rahul Gandhi's remarks at the University of Chicago expose the Congress party's glaring hypocrisy on Palestine. At a time when Gaza is witnessing one of the most devastating genocides of our time, with thousands of innocent children among its victims, he openly advocates stronger ties with Israel and arms purchases from a state responsible for their slaughter,' Vijayan wrote.
Vijayan further argued that Gandhi's position 'undermines the legacy of Nehru, whose foreign policy stood firmly against imperialism and in solidarity with the Palestinian struggle,' adding: 'There can be no balancing act when humanity is on trial.'
The Broader Political Context
The exchange lays bare a fault line within India's opposition ecosystem. The Indian National Congress (INC) and the Communist Party of India (Marxist) — both part of the INDIA alliance — have historically differed on foreign policy, particularly on West Asia. This is not the first time Vijayan and Gandhi have found themselves on opposite sides of a geopolitical question, but the public nature of this disagreement, amplified by a high-profile overseas speech, marks a notable sharpening of that divide. India has historically maintained a two-state solution position at the United Nations while also deepening defence and technology ties with Israel in recent years.
As the conflict in Gaza continues to generate political debate globally, the Congress party's calibrated stance — condemning both the Hamas attacks and Israel's military response — appears aimed at navigating competing pressures from coalition partners, Muslim voters, and India's established foreign policy tradition.