Pakistan cannot lecture India on J&K while using drones on PoJK protesters
Synopsis
Key Takeaways
A detailed report has found that Pakistan is in no position to lecture India on the administration of the Union Territory of Jammu and Kashmir, internet restrictions, or counter-terrorism measures, given that its own security forces have responded to civic governance demands in Pakistan-occupied Jammu and Kashmir (PoJK) with drones, live ammunition, and prolonged communication blackouts. The report underscores a stark double standard at the heart of Islamabad's public posture on Kashmir.
What the Report Found
According to the report published in India Narrative, Islamabad routinely raises concerns about New Delhi's governance of Jammu and Kashmir, including internet restrictions and counter-terrorism operations against cross-border militancy. Yet in PoJK, Pakistani authorities have invoked anti-terrorism laws, deployed lethal force, enforced communication blackouts, and cracked down on press freedom in response to residents demanding better governance, affordable electricity, political representation, and the implementation of previously agreed terms.
The Rawalakot Crackdown of November 2025
The most recent escalation, according to the report, took place in the Rawalakot area of PoJK on 5 November, when Pakistan Rangers and local police moved to disperse sit-in protests that had persisted for months. Reports cited by Amnesty International and local activists describe the use of live ammunition and drones, resulting in the deaths of at least three protesters and injuries to more than a dozen others. Broader tallies from UN human rights experts had earlier noted approximately 96 protester deaths since June — including security personnel — while diaspora activists and groups such as the Jammu Kashmir Human Rights Observatory have documented higher cumulative figures, acknowledging the difficulty of verification amid the blackouts.
International Voices Raise Alarms
Amnesty International has written an open letter to Pakistani authorities urging a prompt, thorough, impartial, effective, and transparent investigation into the deaths and injuries of protesters, as well as what it called the unlawful use of force, including lethal weapons, by security personnel in the occupied territory. Separately, six UN Special Rapporteurs on human rights recently voiced concern over Pakistan's designation of the Joint Awami Action Committee (JAAC) as a terrorist organisation in PoJK, warning that counter-terrorism powers were being misused to suppress political and labour advocacy.
Media Blackout and Documentation Challenges
Communication blackouts and movement restrictions have severely hampered efforts to document developments on the ground. Local journalists have reported difficulties in verifying casualty figures and accessing affected areas, and some independent reporters were reportedly detained for attempting to cover events in the region. Diaspora voices, including those from the United Kashmir People's National Party and activists such as Amjad Ayub Mirza, have alleged enforced disappearances, the withholding of bodies — sometimes reportedly contingent on families declaring the deceased 'terrorists' — and the deployment of paramilitary forces against peaceful civic gatherings.
What Genuine Accountability Requires
The report argues that authentic accountability demands independent investigations, restoration of communication services and media access, meaningful dialogue with local representatives, and an end to the pattern of suppressing local voices. It draws a direct line between Islamabad's rhetorical posture on Jammu and Kashmir and its own conduct in the territory it administers — a contradiction, the report contends, that the international community cannot overlook.