Bihar MLC disqualification petitions dismissed on procedural grounds
Synopsis
Key Takeaways
The Bihar Legislative Council Secretariat on 18 November 2026 dismissed all petitions seeking the disqualification of two newly-elected Independent members — Banshidhar Brajwasi and Rahul Raj — under the anti-defection law, granting both legislators temporary relief from a challenge to their membership. The petitions had accused the two MLCs of joining the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) shortly after winning their seats as Independent candidates.
What the Secretariat Ruled
The decision to dismiss the petitions was taken on the directions of the Acting Chairman of the Legislative Council. Deputy Secretary Manoj Kumar issued separate official letters to petitioners, citing failure to meet the legal and procedural standards required under the Tenth Schedule of the Constitution and the Bihar Legislative Council Members' Rules, 1994. The applications were found unfit for consideration and rejected at the preliminary stage itself.
Who Filed the Petitions and Why They Were Rejected
Two sets of petitioners had approached the Secretariat. Five Rashtriya Janata Dal (RJD) leaders — Abdul Bari Siddiqui, Dr Sunil Kumar Singh, Shashi Yadav, Rajiv Kumar, and Afaq Ahmed — filed petitions seeking action against Brajwasi and Rahul Raj. Their applications were dismissed on procedural grounds, including failure to use the prescribed format and deficiencies in the required affidavits and verification process.
Five other applicants — including Jan Suraaj leader and former MLA Kishor Kumar, Sandeep Kumar, advocate Ramesh Kumar Singh Chandel, Rupesh Kumar Kunwar, and Vimohan Kumar — were rejected on a separate legal ground: only a sitting member of the Legislative Council is entitled to file a disqualification petition. Individuals who are not members of the House do not have the authority to initiate such proceedings, the Secretariat stated.
The Controversy: BJP Scarves and Membership Receipts
The dispute originated shortly after Brajwasi and Rahul Raj won the Bihar Legislative Council elections as Independent candidates. Within days of their victory, both visited the BJP office in Patna. Photographs subsequently emerged showing the two wearing BJP scarves and holding what appeared to be membership receipts, triggering allegations from the RJD and Jan Suraaj that they had formally joined the ruling party.
Both MLCs and the BJP denied a formal merger, maintaining that the two had extended only external support and had not become full members of the party. This distinction is legally significant: the Tenth Schedule applies to formal party membership, not to external support arrangements.
What This Means Going Forward
With all petitions dismissed on procedural and legal grounds, Brajwasi and Rahul Raj have secured temporary relief. Notably, the Secretariat's rejection was not on the merits of the disqualification claim but on procedural deficiencies — meaning fresh, properly filed petitions by eligible members could potentially revive the challenge. This comes amid broader scrutiny of Independent legislators aligning with ruling formations across states, a pattern that has repeatedly tested the limits of anti-defection provisions in India's parliamentary history.