Jamiat opposes Lok Sabha seat expansion, says women's quota must stay within current strength
Synopsis
Key Takeaways
Jamiat Ulama-e-Hind Maharashtra President Maulana Haleemullah Qasmi on 16 November came out against the proposed expansion of Lok Sabha seats linked to the Women's Reservation Bill, asserting that the quota for women must be implemented within the Parliament's existing strength rather than through a fresh delimitation exercise. The remarks, made in Mumbai, signal growing resistance from minority religious organisations to the government's delimitation roadmap.
Opposition to Seat Expansion
Qasmi argued that increasing the number of parliamentary seats was unnecessary and that the energy of the state should instead be directed toward strengthening elected representatives and workers at the grassroots level. He drew a sharp distinction between lawmakers at Parliament level and ground-level workers who, in his view, have more direct impact on citizens.
'Women should be given reservation within the existing strength. If at all, the strength of MLAs and ground workers should be increased because they are the ones who engage with the public. That will make a difference. If we increase seats in Parliament any further, it will soon become a fish market,' Qasmi said.
Delimitation Seen as Benefiting Hindi-Belt States
Questioning the rationale of clubbing the Women's Reservation Bill with delimitation, Qasmi alleged that the exercise was designed to favour Hindi-speaking states with larger populations. He contended that the governing establishment was aware it stood to gain electorally from population-based seat redistribution in the Hindi heartland, and that linking women's reservation to that process 'makes no sense.'
This critique echoes concerns raised by several southern states, which have argued that any population-based delimitation would reduce their proportional representation in Parliament — a tension that has been building since the 2001 population freeze was extended.
Remarks on West Bengal Law and Order
Turning to West Bengal, Qasmi alleged a deteriorating law-and-order situation, claiming Members of Parliament had been gheraoed and attacked. He attributed the disorder to governance failures and questioned police explanations in encounter cases in the state.
'The police's statement on the issue is a cliché: that the criminals attacked, and they responded to the situation, and thus, the criminal was encountered. However, we all know the truth behind it,' he said, adding that such actions were unacceptable under any government.
Critique of BJP and RSS
Qasmi accused the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) of pursuing divisive politics aimed at creating fault lines between Hindus and Muslims. Referring to RSS chief Mohan Bhagwat, he said he respected the position but perceived a gap between Bhagwat's public statements and the conduct of those affiliated with the organisation. He urged Bhagwat to actively guide the BJP leadership away from what he characterised as a politics of division.
Qasmi also commented on Prime Minister Narendra Modi's foreign policy, saying that Modi's praise for US President Donald Trump during visits to the United States had set an example that others within the country had drawn upon.
What to Watch
The delimitation commission's timeline and the government's response to such opposition voices will determine whether the Women's Reservation Bill's implementation schedule faces further political friction ahead of the next general election cycle.