Kishan Reddy corners Congress over SIR U-turn in Andaman
Synopsis
Key Takeaways
A Sanskrit shloka about the gap between what noble souls profess and what the crooked practise. That is how Union Coal and Mines Minister G. Kishan Reddy chose to open his broadside on Wednesday, 18 November 2026 — and the target was Congress's handling of the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls.
A year of charges, then a letter from Andaman
For more than twelve months, Congress mounted a full-throated campaign against SIR. Leader of Opposition Rahul Gandhi branded it 'a new weapon for vote theft.' Congress President Mallikarjun Kharge called it a 'Frankenstein Monster.' Senior leader Jairam Ramesh labelled it 'a method of disenfranchising Indians.' Telangana Chief Minister Revanth Reddy went further, declaring it 'the single largest disenfranchisement exercise on planet earth.' The party questioned the credibility of the Election Commission of India itself, with Gandhi likening the body to an accomplice.
Then came 14 November 2026. According to Reddy's post, the Congress unit in Andaman & Nicobar Islands wrote to the Chief Electoral Officer requesting that the latest SIR rolls be used as the 'primary basis' for the 2027 municipal and panchayat polls in the Union Territory — the very rolls the party had spent a year denouncing.
Reddy's two-question trap for Rahul Gandhi
Kishan Reddy framed the contradiction as a binary with no clean exit. If SIR rolls are 'vote chori' — vote theft — why is Congress asking to fight elections on them in Andaman? If they are not, why did Gandhi mislead the country for a year, including by undertaking what Reddy describes as a 'yatra' against the revision process?
'Rahul Gandhi cannot attack SIR in Delhi while his party asks for it in Andaman,' the minister wrote. He extended the demand to Revanth Reddy as well: the Telangana CM, who had used the starkest language of all, 'owes Telangana the same answer.'
SIR and the long war over electoral rolls
The Election Commission of India conducts periodic intensive and summary revisions of voter rolls under the Representation of the People Act, updating lists ahead of polls to remove dead or shifted voters and add new eligible citizens. Opposition parties have historically argued that aggressive purges risk dropping genuine voters — often marginalised communities — while the ruling establishment presents the exercise as an anti-fraud clean-up. That fault line is not new, but Kishan Reddy's post weaponises an internal contradiction within Congress rather than rehashing the original debate.
The BJP's Telangana state president closed with a verdict that doubles as a hashtag: 'One party. Two faces.' — and the tag #CongressHypocrisy. No Congress spokesperson had publicly responded to the Andaman letter allegation at the time of publication.
The 2027 local body polls in the Andaman & Nicobar Islands are still months away — but the political cost of that one administrative letter, if confirmed, may prove far harder to revise than any electoral roll.