Kumaraswamy slams Sonia Gandhi over Vande Mataram row in Karnataka

Share:
Audio Loading voice…
Kumaraswamy slams Sonia Gandhi over Vande Mataram row in Karnataka

Synopsis

Union Minister H.D. Kumaraswamy questioned Sonia Gandhi's Indian identity in a sharp attack over the Vande Mataram controversy, while also targeting the Karnataka Congress government over the Hanur forest firing and a 500-day farmer agitation against land acquisition in Bidadi — making it one of his most wide-ranging political offensives in recent weeks.

Key Takeaways

Kumaraswamy attacked Sonia Gandhi over alleged opposition to Vande Mataram , questioning her Indian identity at a press meet in Holenarasipura, Hassan on Monday .
He recalled that Vande Mataram was sung at a Congress session attended by Mahatma Gandhi and by Nobel laureate Rabindranath Tagore .
On the Hanur shooting , Kumaraswamy said the manner in which forest personnel opened fire was 'wrong' and called for better opportunities to prevent such tragedies.
He alleged farmers and women farmers had protested land acquisition for around 500 days in the Bidadi area and accused the government of intimidation.
Kumaraswamy demanded public release of the Kagodu Thimappa Committee report, which he claimed recommended against the disputed township project.

Union Minister for Heavy Industries and Steel H.D. Kumaraswamy on Monday launched a sharp attack on Congress leader Sonia Gandhi over her alleged opposition to the singing of Vande Mataram, asserting that every citizen must respect the national song. Kumaraswamy made the remarks while speaking to reporters in Holenarasipura, Hassan district, Karnataka.

Kumaraswamy's Attack on Sonia Gandhi

When reporters raised allegations that Sonia Gandhi had objected to the singing of Vande Mataram, Kumaraswamy did not hold back. He remarked: 'What else can one expect from Sonia Gandhi? Is Sonia Gandhi from our country? She came to our country after marriage. The blood flowing in her is Italian blood, isn't it?'

The minister stressed that Parliament had formally recognised that the song — written by Bankim Chandra Chatterjee — deserves due respect. He recalled that Vande Mataram had been sung at a Congress session attended by Mahatma Gandhi, and that Nobel laureate Rabindranath Tagore had also sung it. Kumaraswamy accused the Congress of displaying 'narrow-mindedness' on the issue and warned that the party would face further electoral consequences.

Hanur Shooting Incident

Kumaraswamy also addressed the recent shooting incident in Hanur, where three members of the same family died. He said the anger and grief of the affected families and local farmers was 'understandable' and 'natural.' The government had claimed the deceased had entered the forest for deer hunting, and Chief Minister D.K. Shivakumar had ordered an investigation.

Kumaraswamy questioned the manner in which forest personnel opened fire. 'That was wrong. If they had fired at the legs or in a manner that did not pose a threat to life, everyone would have accepted it,' he said. He called on the government to create better opportunities and a secure future to prevent such incidents.

Bidadi Padayatra and Land Acquisition Row

The minister turned his fire on the Congress government's advertisements related to the Bidadi padayatra, challenging Chief Minister Shivakumar to release the findings of the government's own fact-finding committee. Kumaraswamy alleged that farmers and women farmers had opposed land acquisition and had been protesting for around 500 days.

'Farmers and women farmers have clearly said that they will not give their land. Why are you using force and allegedly sending rowdies to intimidate them? What are you trying to achieve by threatening that grant land will be taken back if people do not surrender their land?' he asked.

Kagodu Thimappa Committee Report

Kumaraswamy demanded that the Karnataka government make public the report of the Kagodu Thimappa Committee, which he claimed had recommended against establishing a township at the disputed location under any circumstances. He also questioned why the government was insisting on the township project when, according to him, alternative land was available elsewhere.

Taking a dig at the Chief Minister, Kumaraswamy said: 'Print the recommendations you made at that time and publish them as advertisements. If you do that, it will save us some money on advertisements as well.' With assembly politics heating up, Kumaraswamy's multi-pronged attack signals that the Janata Dal (Secular)Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) combine intends to keep pressure on the Karnataka Congress government on multiple fronts.

Point of View

But it risks diverting attention from substantive governance questions he himself raised: the Hanur forest firing, a 500-day farmer agitation, and a suppressed committee report on the Bidadi township. The Kagodu Thimappa Committee angle, if the report says what Kumaraswamy claims, is the most newsworthy element of this press conference — yet it is likely to be buried under the Vande Mataram headline. Karnataka's ruling Congress has so far not released that report, and that silence deserves as much scrutiny as the minister's rhetoric.
NationPress
17 Aug 2026

Frequently Asked Questions

What did Kumaraswamy say about Sonia Gandhi and Vande Mataram?
H.D. Kumaraswamy alleged that Sonia Gandhi had objected to the singing of Vande Mataram and questioned her Indian identity, saying 'the blood flowing in her is Italian blood.' He argued that Parliament has recognised the song written by Bankim Chandra Chatterjee deserves due respect, and that Congress was displaying narrow-mindedness on the issue.
What is the Hanur shooting incident Kumaraswamy referred to?
The Hanur shooting incident involved the deaths of three members of the same family, reportedly after forest personnel opened fire. The government claimed the deceased had entered the forest for deer hunting, and Chief Minister D.K. Shivakumar ordered an investigation. Kumaraswamy called the manner of firing 'wrong' and said targeted, non-lethal firing would have been more appropriate.
What is the Bidadi padayatra land acquisition controversy?
Kumaraswamy alleged that farmers and women farmers in the Bidadi area have been protesting land acquisition for around 500 days, refusing to surrender their land. He accused the Karnataka government of using force and allegedly sending rowdies to intimidate protesters, and of threatening to take back grant land from those who resist.
What is the Kagodu Thimappa Committee report?
The Kagodu Thimappa Committee is a panel whose report Kumaraswamy claims recommended against establishing a township at the Bidadi site under any circumstances. He challenged Chief Minister D.K. Shivakumar to make the report public, alleging the government has suppressed findings that contradict its own project.
What is Kumaraswamy's political position in Karnataka?
H.D. Kumaraswamy is a Union Minister for Heavy Industries and Steel and a leader of the Janata Dal (Secular), which is allied with the Bharatiya Janata Party at the national level. He is a prominent opposition voice against the Congress government currently in power in Karnataka.
Nation Press
The Trail

Connected Dots

Tracing the thread behind this story — newest first.

8 Dots
  1. Latest 1 hour ago
  2. 2 hours ago
  3. 2 hours ago
  4. 14 hours ago
  5. Yesterday
  6. 2 days ago
  7. 2 days ago
  8. 8 months ago
Google Prefer NP
On Google