Operation Sindoor row: BJP demands apology from Himachal minister Jagat Singh Negi

Share:
Audio Loading voice…
Operation Sindoor row: BJP demands apology from Himachal minister Jagat Singh Negi

Synopsis

A Revenue Minister's remarks inside the Himachal Pradesh Assembly — linking Operation Sindoor to what he called India's struggle and questioning the Rafale procurement — set off a firestorm. The BJP staged a walkout, the Speaker adjourned the House, and the Leader of Opposition warned of continued disruption. At the heart of it: a clash over whether legitimate defence procurement questions can be raised in a state legislature without being branded anti-Army.

Key Takeaways

Himachal Pradesh Revenue Minister Jagat Singh Negi (Congress) sparked a row on 19 November 2026 with remarks about Operation Sindoor and the Rafale fighter jet procurement inside the state Assembly.
The BJP demanded an apology, staged a protest outside the Assembly, moved an adjournment motion, and walked out of the House.
Negi refused to apologise, insisting his remarks were taken out of context and were directed at corruption in defence procurement, not at the armed forces.
Leader of Opposition Jai Ram Thakur warned of continued disruption if Negi does not apologise.
Speaker Sanjay Rattan was forced to adjourn proceedings after repeated disruptions from both sides.
The BJP alleged the Congress leadership was shielding Negi rather than taking action against him.

A sharp political dispute has broken out in the Himachal Pradesh Assembly in Dharamsala after State Revenue Minister Jagat Singh Negi of the Congress made remarks about Operation Sindoor that the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) condemned as objectionable and 'anti-national'. The controversy dominated the third day of the Winter session on Thursday, 19 November 2026, forcing the Speaker to adjourn proceedings.

What Minister Negi Said

Minister Negi reportedly stated inside the Assembly that during Operation Sindoor, it was India — not Pakistan — that had been left struggling. He also raised allegations of corruption in the procurement of Rafale fighter jets, questioning the purchase process. Speaking to the media after the uproar, Negi clarified that his remarks were directed at the Rafale deal and not at the courage or valour of the Indian armed forces. He said the BJP had deliberately linked his comments to the military to divert attention from the actual corruption allegations under discussion and to manufacture a fresh controversy.

Negi also accused BJP leaders of presenting his remarks out of context, noting that the full proceedings of the House were on record. 'Those asking me to apologise should themselves feel ashamed,' he said, refusing to back down from his position.

BJP's Protest and Demands

The BJP staged a protest outside the Himachal Pradesh Assembly, accusing Negi of making objectionable remarks against the Indian Army. Former Chief Minister and Leader of Opposition Jai Ram Thakur alleged that the Revenue Minister had made 'baseless accusations of corruption' within the armed forces and had made 'serious and completely unacceptable comments' about Operation Sindoor. Thakur contended that Negi, holding a constitutional office and bound by an oath to uphold the Constitution, had no business making such statements.

The BJP Legislature Party moved an adjournment motion and subsequently staged a walkout. Thakur warned that if Negi did not apologise, the Opposition would disrupt Assembly proceedings again. He also questioned why the Congress high command had not taken action, alleging the party was shielding its leaders instead of holding them accountable.

Speaker Adjourns the House

The heated exchanges between the ruling Congress and the Opposition BJP escalated after BJP MLA Rakesh Jamwal raised the matter in the House, sparking a debate over corruption allegations. Repeated disruptions ultimately forced Speaker Sanjay Rattan to adjourn proceedings. The BJP also alleged that Negi continued speaking despite Opposition objections and that the controversial remarks were recorded in the official proceedings of the Assembly.

Congress Counter-Charge

The Congress camp maintained that Negi's remarks had been misrepresented. The Minister argued that his questions concerned the procurement and deployment of Rafale aircraft during Operation Sindoor, and that any attempt to frame them as an attack on the armed forces was a political manoeuvre. He accused the BJP of using the armed forces as a shield to gain political mileage and deflect scrutiny from legitimate questions about defence procurement.

Broader Context

This is not the first time Operation Sindoor — the Indian military operation that drew intense national attention — has become a flashpoint in state-level legislative debates. Opposition parties across several states have sought to capitalise on public sentiment around the operation, while Congress leaders in some assemblies have faced backlash for perceived scepticism. The Himachal episode reflects a wider pattern in which national security themes increasingly dominate state legislature proceedings, often at the expense of substantive policy debate. With the Winter session still under way, further disruptions appear likely unless both sides agree to a resolution.

Point of View

Where any questioning of military outcomes — however framed — risks being weaponised as anti-nationalist. Negi's core argument, that defence procurement deserves legislative scrutiny, is entirely legitimate; Rafale has been a contested procurement since 2019. But by coupling it with a claim about India 'struggling,' he handed the BJP an easy target. The Congress leadership's silence is notable — it neither defended the substance of the corruption allegation nor distanced itself from the framing. That ambiguity is itself a political choice, and one that appears to have cost the party the news cycle.
NationPress
19 Nov 2026

Frequently Asked Questions

What did Himachal minister Jagat Singh Negi say about Operation Sindoor?
Negi reportedly said inside the Himachal Pradesh Assembly that during Operation Sindoor, it was India — not Pakistan — that had been left struggling. He also alleged corruption in the procurement of Rafale fighter jets. He later clarified that his remarks were about the Rafale deal and not intended to question the Indian armed forces.
Why is the BJP demanding an apology from Minister Negi?
The BJP contends that Negi's remarks were objectionable and amounted to making baseless corruption accusations against the Indian Army and undermining the significance of Operation Sindoor. Leader of Opposition Jai Ram Thakur called the comments 'completely unacceptable' and accused Negi of violating his constitutional oath.
What happened in the Himachal Pradesh Assembly session on 19 November?
On the third day of the Winter session, a heated debate erupted after BJP MLA Rakesh Jamwal raised the issue. The BJP moved an adjournment motion, staged a walkout, and protested outside the Assembly. Speaker Sanjay Rattan was forced to adjourn proceedings due to repeated disruptions.
How has Minister Negi responded to the BJP's demands?
Negi refused to apologise, saying those demanding one should feel ashamed. He argued his remarks were taken out of context and that the BJP deliberately linked them to the armed forces to divert attention from legitimate corruption questions about the Rafale procurement.
What is the BJP threatening if Negi does not apologise?
Leader of Opposition Jai Ram Thakur warned that if Negi does not issue an apology, the Opposition will be compelled to disrupt the Winter session of the Himachal Pradesh Assembly again. He also called on the Congress high command to take action against Negi.
Nation Press
The Trail

Connected Dots

Tracing the thread behind this story — newest first.

8 Dots
  1. Latest 2 hours ago
  2. 6 months ago
  3. 1 year ago
  4. 1 year ago
  5. 1 year ago
  6. 1 year ago
  7. 1 year ago
  8. 1 year ago
Google Prefer NP
On Google