Pakistan courts under executive control after 26th, 27th amendments: ICJ
Synopsis
Key Takeaways
The International Commission of Jurists (ICJ) has concluded that a series of constitutional changes in Pakistan have effectively placed the country's highest courts under executive control, stripping the judiciary of the independence required under international law. The Geneva-based rights body released its findings on Wednesday, 19 November 2026, in a report titled Judicial Capture: Independence of the Judiciary in Pakistan after the 26th and 27th Constitutional Amendments.
What the ICJ Found
The report examines the legal framework now governing Pakistan's High Courts, the Supreme Court, and the Federal Constitutional Court in light of the country's obligations under international law. It concludes that the amendments, along with the manner in which they were implemented, have stripped Pakistan's top courts of the independence guarantees required under Article 14 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) and the UN Basic Principles on the Independence of the Judiciary.
The report comes one year after the 27th amendment was passed in November 2025, and two years after the 26th amendment was passed in October 2024.
ICJ Secretary-General's Warning
ICJ Secretary-General Santiago Canton said the two amendments had 'placed Pakistan's highest courts under the control of the executive.' He warned that once courts are captured, there is no institution left to hold the government accountable, and victims of rights abuses are left without recourse.
Canton acknowledged that Pakistan's judiciary had been in need of reform — citing opaque appointment processes and instances of courts overstepping into legislative or executive domains. However, he argued that none of those underlying problems had been addressed. Instead, according to Canton, the government had exploited public frustration with the courts as a pretext to bring them fully under political control.
Impact on Human Rights and Democracy
The ICJ directly linked the erosion of judicial independence to a broader pattern of democratic backsliding in Pakistan. It said the changes had seriously weakened the judiciary's capacity to serve as a check on the government and had undermined victims' right to an effective remedy under Article 2(3) of the ICCPR — a treaty to which Pakistan is a signatory.
Notably, the report frames judicial capture not merely as an institutional concern but as a human rights crisis, arguing that citizens alleging abuses now have no independent forum in which to seek justice.
What the ICJ Is Demanding
The body has called for all provisions within the 26th and 27th amendments that are inconsistent with international standards on judicial independence to be either revised or repealed. The ICJ stopped short of specifying a timeline, but the report signals that international scrutiny of Pakistan's legal reforms is intensifying.
This is not the first time Pakistan's constitutional amendments have drawn international concern — the country's judiciary has faced recurring criticism over interference from both civilian governments and the military establishment. With the ICJ now formally documenting 'judicial capture,' pressure on Islamabad from multilateral human rights bodies is likely to grow.