Jaishankar in New York: 'Diplomacy has become an extreme sport'
Synopsis
Key Takeaways
External Affairs Minister S. Jaishankar on 29 September painted a stark picture of a world destabilised by wars, economic coercion and weaponised interdependence, warning that diplomats today operate in an environment of 'unusually high risk' as nations scramble for strategic advantage. Speaking at an event in New York, Jaishankar offered one of his most candid assessments yet of the fracturing global order.
Wars, Choke Points and Economic Pressure
Jaishankar pointed to two major ongoing conflicts, turmoil across West Asia, active fighting in parts of Africa and mounting financial strain on developing nations as evidence of a world under simultaneous stress. Food, fuel, fertilisers and finance were all under pressure, he said, while global supply chains were growing more fragile by the month.
He identified what he called 'choke points' — geographical corridors, sanctions regimes, travel restrictions and market access — as tools that powerful countries were increasingly willing to deploy against rivals. Energy disruptions in major producing regions had already forced price adjustments worldwide, he noted, while advances in military technology were lowering the threshold for risk-taking among governments.
The Paradox of Interdependence
At the heart of Jaishankar's argument was what he described as 'the paradox of our times': nations remain deeply economically intertwined, yet are growing more tempted to exploit those very connections as instruments of leverage. 'The interdependence is the reality, the competition is the sentiment,' he said. When one country depends on another for a critical resource or supply, intense rivalry creates an incentive to convert that dependence into a pressure point, he argued.
This dynamic, he said, had produced a more hazardous environment for governments trying to protect national interests without severing essential relationships. The world had also grown more impatient — where deterrence once served as a stabilising force, countries with new military or technological capabilities now faced a temptation to use them before rivals could close the gap. He characterised this as a 'use it or lose it' mindset.
'Diplomacy Has Become an Extreme Sport'
Jaishankar reserved his sharpest formulation for the profession of diplomacy itself. 'Diplomacy has become an extreme sport,' he said, describing how envoys must navigate high-stakes decisions and their cascading consequences while retaining the patience required for protracted negotiations. The remark underscored his view that traditional diplomatic tools are being stress-tested by a pace and complexity of crises unlike anything in recent memory.
Institutions Under Strain
The minister also questioned whether multilateral institutions designed under a previous balance of power could remain relevant. He noted that the United Nations was founded in 1945 with just 51 members, in a world fundamentally different from today's. Its future credibility, he suggested, depended on how effectively it adapted to present-day realities — a pointed remark given India's long-standing push for reform of the UN Security Council and greater representation for developing nations.
Jaishankar noted that rising economies and those experiencing relative decline were both adjusting to a shift in global power, generating uncertainty that was spilling into domestic politics across multiple countries. India, he said, was among those actively seeking new partnerships and diversifying its strategic relationships to reduce exposure to single points of failure — a posture reflected in its simultaneous engagement through the G20, BRICS and the Quad.
A Cautious Optimism
Despite the sombre diagnosis, Jaishankar stopped short of outright pessimism. 'I'm not pessimistic about the world,' he said during the discussion that followed his remarks. Countries retained a shared interest in reaching stable and reliable arrangements, even as competition intensified. New understandings could emerge, he said, though he expected the path to them to be difficult. The remarks signal that New Delhi is preparing for a prolonged period of geopolitical turbulence — and positioning itself to navigate it on its own terms.