US Democrats propose Protect Our Neighbors Act after Harjit Kaur deportation
Synopsis
Key Takeaways
Four Democratic lawmakers from California have introduced legislation that would allow decades-old deportation orders to expire and open a pathway to permanent residence for long-settled immigrants — directly citing the case of Harjit Kaur, a Sikh grandmother deported to India after more than 30 years in the United States. The Protect Our Neighbors Act was announced on Thursday, 20 November 2026, by Representatives Lateefah Simon, John Garamendi, Zoe Lofgren, and Juan Vargas.
The Case That Drove the Bill
Harjit Kaur had lived in the US since the early 1990s and complied with immigration requirements, reportedly checking in with authorities every six months for more than 13 years. She was detained during a routine immigration check-in in September 2025 and subsequently deported to India, despite her long record of compliance and deep community roots.
Her family described the experience in stark terms. 'We are still traumatized and horrified by the cruel treatment of our grandmother one year ago,' the family said in a statement released through Representative Simon's office. They described Kaur as a central figure in both family life and the wider community, having raised children and grandchildren during her decades in America.
What the Legislation Proposes
The published bill would make final removal orders expire 10 years after issuance. An immigration judge could renew an expired order at the Homeland Security Secretary's request, but only upon clear and convincing evidence of significant reasons for the delay — unrelated to administrative or funding problems — and new evidence establishing that renewal served the public interest.
Immigrants whose orders had expired and were not renewed could seek lawful status after at least 10 years of continuous US presence, provided they had no conviction for an offence punishable by more than a year in prison. A renewal would be barred while such a petition was pending.
A separate provision would allow discretionary permanent residence for certain individuals physically present in the US with longstanding orders based on specified immigration grounds. Applications would require a fee capped at $1,200 and a certified copy of the applicant's latest federal income-tax return. Critically, neither order expiration nor a pending application would automatically confer a green card.
Lawmakers' Argument
The sponsors argued that immigrants whose removal had been deferred for years had built families, worked, and established community ties while remaining perpetually vulnerable to deportation. 'We need a sensible immigration policy for those who have resided peacefully for a long time in America,' Representative Lofgren said.
Garamendi's office framed Kaur's experience as emblematic of the broader uncertainty facing longstanding residents with unresolved immigration status — people who have remained in contact with authorities yet lack a clear legal pathway to stability.
Context and What Comes Next
The bill comes amid a broader national debate over the treatment of long-settled immigrants with unresolved legal status, a cohort that advocates argue has grown substantially over decades of deferred enforcement. This is not the first time California lawmakers have pushed for relief provisions, but the Kaur case has given the effort a specific, high-profile human anchor.
The legislation faces an uncertain path in Congress, where immigration reform proposals have repeatedly stalled. Its introduction, however, signals renewed Democratic intent to put individual deportation cases at the centre of a legislative argument. How Republican counterparts respond — and whether the bill attracts bipartisan support — will determine its chances of advancing beyond committee.