Nagaur MP Hanuman Beniwal Raises Alarm Over Forced Smart Meter Implementation in Lok Sabha
Synopsis
In a recent Lok Sabha session, MP Hanuman Beniwal voiced serious concerns regarding the forced installation of smart meters across several states, including Rajasthan, which he claims infringes on consumer rights and is a step towards hidden privatisation of the power sector.
Key Takeaways
Forced Installation: Smart meters are allegedly being imposed on consumers.
Consumer Rights: Beniwal emphasizes the violation of consumer rights.
Public Discontent: There is significant public opposition to smart meters.
CAPF Concerns: Beniwal raised multiple issues concerning paramilitary personnel.
Government Accountability: The need for better transparency and monitoring is highlighted.
Jaipur, April 2 (NationPress) Hanuman Beniwal, the chief of the Rashtriya Loktantrik Party and MP from Nagaur, expressed his apprehensions in the Lok Sabha regarding the implementation of smart meters. He accused the government of enforcing these meters on consumers across various states, including Rajasthan.
In response to his inquiry, Union Minister Manohar Lal Khattar stated that the government lacks relevant information.
Beniwal criticized the rollout, describing it as a move towards the “hidden privatisation” of the electricity sector and a breach of consumer rights.
He highlighted the significant public discontent regarding smart meters and referenced Section 47(5) of the Electricity Act, 2003, which permits the installation of prepaid meters only at the request of consumers.
Despite this regulation, he alleged that these meters are being installed against the will of consumers, often favoring private contractors.
Beniwal sought information on states reporting a rise in complaints related to inaccurate billing and sudden disconnections following the installation of prepaid meters. He also inquired whether the government has an independent monitoring system to curb these irregularities.
According to Beniwal, the government failed to provide a satisfactory answer. He reiterated that smart meters should not be mandatory for consumers.
While discussing the CAPF (General Administration) Bill, 2026, Beniwal made several demands addressing the needs of paramilitary personnel and their families.
His requests included reinstating the Old Pension Scheme, ensuring representation for CAPF officers in the Pay Commission, granting ‘martyr’ status to personnel who die in the line of duty, GST exemptions for canteens, and enhancements in medical services, housing, education, and welfare infrastructure.
Additionally, he advocated for improved promotion opportunities for constables and head constables, alongside reservation and support for families of martyred officials.
Beniwal opposed the Agniveer scheme, urging a return to the conventional Army recruitment process.
Criticizing the Bill, he claimed it was introduced without sufficient consideration and would not withstand scrutiny for justice and fairness.
Paying homage to CAPF personnel who lost their lives in terror and Naxal attacks, he emphasized their vital role in elections, internal security, and border management, asserting the need to fully protect their rights.
Point of View
The concerns raised by MP Hanuman Beniwal regarding the forced implementation of smart meters highlight significant issues surrounding consumer rights and government accountability. His call for safeguards indicates a growing public discontent that authorities must address to maintain trust and transparency in the energy sector.
NationPress
14 Jul 2026
Frequently Asked Questions
What did Hanuman Beniwal say about smart meters?
He raised concerns in the Lok Sabha that smart meters are being imposed on consumers without their consent, violating consumer rights.
What are the implications of Section 47(5) of the Electricity Act, 2003?
This section states that prepaid meters can only be installed at the request of consumers, which Beniwal argues is being ignored.
What demands did Beniwal make regarding paramilitary personnel?
He called for the restoration of the Old Pension Scheme, better promotions for personnel, and GST exemptions for canteens.
How did the government respond to Beniwal's concerns?
Union Minister Manohar Lal Khattar stated that the government does not have information regarding the allegations about smart meters.
What did Beniwal accuse the rollout of smart meters of being?
He described the rollout as a move towards the hidden privatisation of the power sector.
