Shuddhikaran row: CM Dhami says no caste bias in Uttarakhand, hits Congress
Synopsis
Key Takeaways
Uttarakhand Chief Minister Pushkar Singh Dhami on Saturday, 29 August distanced the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) from the 'shuddhikaran' (purification) controversy in Haldwani, asserting that those who conducted the ritual at the Ramlila ground were neither BJP office-bearers nor party workers. The controversy erupted after Congress president Mallikarjun Kharge addressed a public rally at the venue.
What Dhami Said About the Ritual
Speaking to reporters, CM Dhami stated that the purification programme was organised by religious organisations — not the BJP — in protest against what he described as religiously provocative slogans and an alleged act of desecration at the Ramlila venue. 'The way religious fanatic slogans were raised there, and the defilement was done there... It was a pure place, a religious place where Ramlila is staged,' he said. He attributed the slogans and alleged desecration to 'people of a particular religion,' without naming any group.
Dhami's Charge: Congress Has Become 'Issueless'
The Chief Minister accused the Congress of manufacturing a controversy for electoral advantage. 'In protest against this, religious organisations organised a purification programme there. And in this, I feel that the Congress party has become issueless. Now, they are raising unnecessary issues,' Dhami said. He questioned whether any resident of Uttarakhand would acknowledge caste discrimination in the state, framing the controversy as a politically motivated narrative.
BJP's Record on Dalit Inclusion, Per Dhami
Dhami invoked the BJP-led Centre's governance under Prime Minister Narendra Modi, citing the 'Sabka Saath, Sabka Vikas, Sabka Vishwas, Sabka Prayas' framework as evidence of inclusive politics. He contrasted this with what he characterised as the Congress's historical treatment of Dalit leaders, specifically referencing former Congress president Sitaram Kesri, former Deputy Prime Minister Babu Jagjivan Ram, and Dr Bhimrao Ambedkar. 'They were never allowed to receive the Bharat Ratna, nor were they allowed to enter Parliament,' Dhami alleged, referring to Ambedkar.
Rahul Gandhi's Counter-Demand
Leader of Opposition Rahul Gandhi on the same day demanded that PM Modi direct the filing of an FIR against those allegedly involved in the purification of the Ramlila ground. Gandhi framed the episode as part of a broader ideological contest — 'the Constitution on one side and the views of the RSS-BJP on the other' — and urged the government to initiate action under the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act. He also called for justice for Kharge.
The Wider Political Context
The Haldwani episode has sharpened the caste-politics fault line ahead of upcoming electoral cycles in Uttarakhand. Congress has sought to use Kharge's identity as a Dalit leader to frame the purification ritual as a caste-based slight, while the BJP maintains the act was a religious response to provocation, not a targeted insult. Notably, Dhami acknowledged Kharge's seniority, saying, 'He is a respected leader, with many ministers and chief ministers of several states standing behind him,' even as he rejected the Congress narrative. How the controversy plays out in the state's political landscape will depend on whether independent investigation corroborates either side's account.