KMC audit: Only 7% of 160 Kolkata buildings pass safety review after Taratala collapse
Synopsis
Key Takeaways
Just 11 of 160 under-construction multi-storey structures inspected by the Kolkata Municipal Corporation (KMC) have cleared a high-power safety review committee, according to a report submitted on Monday by KMC Commissioner Smita Pandey. The audit — triggered by the collapse of an under-construction warehouse at Taratala on the southern outskirts of Kolkata last month — reveals that only 6.87 per cent of reviewed structures meet the required construction standards.
What the Audit Found
The high-power committee was constituted by the KMC after the Taratala warehouse collapse claimed 16 lives, prompting the corporation to halt construction on all ongoing multi-storey projects within its jurisdiction. Of the 200 under-construction projects identified in the first phase of the review, audit team members physically visited and inspected 160 sites. Only 11 of those passed the committee's scrutiny.
According to a KMC insider, 344 applications for multi-storey building construction were submitted in Kolkata over the last three years. The current audit covers the first phase of that pipeline.
Serious Defects in 23 Structures
Commissioner Pandey told reporters that 23 of the 160 inspected structures showed serious defects, including poor-quality construction materials and what she described as 'extreme indifference to the safety of workers.' 'The way the work was being carried out, ignoring building codes and regulations, cannot rule out the possibility of a major accident at any time,' Pandey said.
The KMC has directed that work on all 23 flagged buildings be stopped immediately. Files have been returned to the respective developers and promoters for rectification, with no construction permitted until defects are fully resolved in compliance with applicable rules.
Scrutiny of the Previous KMC Board
A key mandate of the high-power committee was to determine whether clearances for these projects had been granted by the previous All India Trinamool Congress (TMC)-run KMC board following proper scrutiny of prescribed construction norms. The audit findings — with fewer than 7 per cent of structures passing review — raise pointed questions about the rigour of approvals granted under that administration.
This comes amid broader concerns about building safety enforcement in West Bengal, where rapid urban construction has outpaced regulatory oversight in several municipal zones.
What Happens Next
Audit reports for the remaining 41 under-construction multi-storey structures have been forwarded to a technical sub-committee for further scrutiny. A final decision on those projects will follow only after the sub-committee issues its assessment. The KMC has not yet indicated a timeline for completing the second phase of inspections covering the remaining projects from the original pool of 344 applications.