Owaisi slams Allahabad HC hijab order as 'attack on Islam', hits out at RSS over Manusmriti
Synopsis
Key Takeaways
All India Majlis-e-Ittehadul Muslimeen (AIMIM) President Asaduddin Owaisi on Tuesday condemned the Allahabad High Court's dismissal of a petition filed by a minor student from Prayagraj, who had sought permission to wear a hijab alongside her prescribed school uniform. Speaking at a Jalsa-e-Rahmatul-lil-Alameen gathering at the AIMIM headquarters in Darussalam, Hyderabad, Owaisi called the verdict an 'attack on Islam' and alleged it violated constitutional provisions.
Owaisi's Challenge to the High Court Ruling
The Allahabad High Court had dismissed the petition on the grounds that the student failed to produce any religious scripture or material establishing that wearing a scarf was an 'essential' part of her faith. The court also noted that photographs submitted in the case showed other students from the same religious community attending school without scarves.
Owaisi rejected this reasoning outright. 'I disagree with this High Court judgment; I do not concur with it... Today's verdict violates Articles 25 and 19 of the Indian Constitution. Who are you to decide what is essential to Islam? Girls are wearing hijab on their heads, not on their minds. It is an attack on Islam,' he said. He further pointed out that the Sabarimala case — which also involves the question of essential religious practices — remains pending before the Supreme Court, arguing that the matter is far from settled in law.
RSS and Manusmriti: A Political Broadside
Owaisi also directed sharp criticism at the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) and the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), alleging that both organisations have historically prioritised Manusmriti over the Indian Constitution. He cited a specific historical claim to make his case.
'I am asking those associated with the RSS about Manusmriti. Is it not true that on 26 November 1949, we adopted the Constitution? However, four days later, on 30 November, a mouthpiece of the RSS published a complaint against it, stating that it 'wasn't a Constitution at all and it should have been the Manusmriti'. They had issues with the Constitution drafted by Babasaheb Ambedkar,' Owaisi said.
Savarkar, Andaman, and Muslim Freedom Fighters
The AIMIM President also targeted Hindutva ideologue V.D. Savarkar, drawing a pointed comparison between his conduct during imprisonment at the Andaman Cellular Jail and that of Muslim freedom fighters. 'Savarkar supported Manusmriti. While imprisoned in Andaman, he was writing letters to the British, saying, 'I am with you, please release me'. On the other hand, what were we (Muslims) doing? Allama Fazl-e-Haq Khairabadi was also in jail; he endured hardships but never wrote a 'love letter' to the British. Instead, he issued a fatwa for Jihad against them. Even today, his grave stands in Andaman as a testament,' he asserted.
Owaisi also claimed that the first prisoner in the Andaman cellular jail was not a figure associated with the RSS or BJP, but 'Hyderabad's Maulvi Alauddin, the Imam of Mecca Masjid'.
UCC Questioned as 'Hindu Personal Law in Disguise'
Turning to the Uniform Civil Code (UCC), which has been implemented in Uttarakhand, Assam, and Gujarat, Owaisi questioned whether laws modelled on existing Hindu personal statutes could legitimately be described as uniform. 'If the laws being enforced are essentially based on provisions of the Hindu Marriage Act, Hindu Divorce Act and Hindu Succession Act, then how can they genuinely be called a Uniform Civil Code? Why should these laws be imposed on Muslims when they are rooted in Hindu personal laws?' he said.
Commitment to Faith and Country
Concluding his address, Owaisi insisted that efforts to distance Muslims from their religious identity would not succeed, while simultaneously reaffirming his community's commitment to India. 'We love this country, we will protect this country, and while remaining committed to our faith, we will work to make India a superpower,' he said, invoking freedom fighters including Turrebaz Khan. All quotes from Owaisi were made at the Hyderabad gathering and have been attributed accordingly. How the BJP and RSS respond to these allegations, and whether the Allahabad HC ruling faces a further legal challenge, will shape the next phase of this debate.