Is There Bias in Loudspeaker Use During Ramzan?
Synopsis
A political controversy has erupted in Uttar Pradesh regarding the use of loudspeakers during Ramzan. SP MLA Kamal Akhtar's demand for inclusion sparked significant reactions from various party leaders, highlighting issues of bias and the need for respect among different communities.
Key Takeaways
Call for Unity: Emphasizing the need for communal harmony during religious observances.
Government Stance: Adherence to Supreme Court guidelines is mandatory for all religious gatherings.
Bipartisan Reactions: Political leaders across parties express varied views on the issue.
Historical Context: Announcements for sehri and iftar have historical significance.
Respect for Diversity: Importance of respecting diverse cultural practices in a pluralistic society.
New Delhi, Feb 20 (NationPress) A political controversy has ignited in Uttar Pradesh following a demand from Samajwadi Party (SP) MLA Kamal Akhtar in the Assembly to permit the use of loudspeakers during Iftar and Sehri throughout Ramzan, sparking strong reactions from leaders across various parties.
During the Zero Hour, Akhtar contended that since all religious festivals — such as Holi, Diwali, Dussehra, Kanwar Yatra, along with celebrations from the Christian and Sikh communities — are celebrated in the state, similar arrangements should be made for announcements from mosques during Ramzan.
In response, Shivpal Singh Yadav, National General Secretary of the Samajwadi Party, accused the government of bias. “This administration is targeting specific communities. They are intentionally making decisions that affect them adversely,” he remarked.
Echoing the call for unity, SP MLA Atul Pradhan stated, “We are advocates of peace, harmony, and brotherhood. Mutual respect is essential for the progress of our nation. Just as cooperation is observed during Navratri, we should also extend the same during Roza and Ramzan to honor one another’s sentiments. Kamal Akhtar is an esteemed leader and chief whip of our party, and we must advance by respecting each other,” he added.
Conversely, Uttar Pradesh Minister Narendra Kashyap asserted that the directives from the Supreme Court regarding loudspeaker usage must be adhered to. “Kamal Akhtar is an experienced member, having served as an MP, and knows the Supreme Court's regulations. Loudspeakers may be utilized at all religious venues, but as per the Supreme Court’s directives, the volume should be moderated according to their guidelines,” he informed IANS.
BJP MLA Rajeshwar Singh commented, “When the Supreme Court has placed restrictions, such requests should not be made. If changes are desired, they should approach the Honorable Supreme Court.”
The Uttar Pradesh government responded by stating that announcements for sehri and iftar originated from a time when clocks were not prevalent, yet it reiterated that the Supreme Court's orders regulating loudspeaker usage continue to apply.
Point of View
I observe that the concerns raised around loudspeaker use during Ramzan reflect the broader challenge of maintaining harmony in a diverse society. It is imperative that all communities feel respected and heard, particularly in matters of cultural significance. The ongoing discourse serves as a reminder of the importance of dialogue and understanding in our nation.
NationPress
20 Jun 2026
Frequently Asked Questions
What was the demand made by SP MLA Kamal Akhtar?
SP MLA Kamal Akhtar demanded the allowance of loudspeakers during Iftar and Sehri in Ramzan to match the consideration given to other religious festivals.
How did other political leaders respond?
Political leaders from both the Samajwadi Party and BJP expressed their views, with some advocating for unity and respect among communities, while others emphasized adherence to Supreme Court directives.
What is the government's position on loudspeaker usage?
The Uttar Pradesh government reiterated that loudspeaker regulations set by the Supreme Court must be followed, regardless of the religious context.
