SC refuses urgent listing of CEC appointment law recall plea before original Bench

Share:
Audio Loading voice…
SC refuses urgent listing of CEC appointment law recall plea before original Bench

Synopsis

The Supreme Court shut the door on an urgent two-judge hearing of a recall plea targeting the reference order on the CEC appointment law — a law that replaced the Chief Justice of India with a PM-nominated minister on the selection panel. With a conflict-of-interest allegation against one retiring judge and a five-judge Constitution Bench already in place, the stage is set for a high-stakes constitutional showdown over India's election machinery.

Key Takeaways

CJI Surya Kant on 20 November 2026 declined to urgently list a recall application before the original two-judge Bench of Justices Dipankar Datta and Satish Chandra Sharma .
Advocate Prashant Bhushan had sought the listing before Justice Sharma's retirement, expected at the end of next week.
The recall plea alleges a conflict of interest against Justice Sharma, noting his son appeared as standing counsel for the Election Commission of India .
The CEC and EC Appointment Act, 2023 replaced the Chief Justice of India on the selection panel with a Union Cabinet Minister nominated by the Prime Minister.
A five-judge Constitution Bench has been constituted and will now hear both the main challenge and the recall application.

The Supreme Court on Friday, 20 November 2026, declined to urgently list a recall application before the original two-judge Bench that had referred challenges to the Chief Election Commissioner and other Election Commissioners (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023 to a Constitution Bench. The ruling came after advocate Prashant Bhushan made a direct appeal to Chief Justice of India (CJI) Surya Kant for special scheduling of the matter.

What Bhushan Sought

Bhushan, appearing for the petitioner, requested that the recall application be urgently listed before the Bench of Justices Dipankar Datta and Satish Chandra Sharma — the same two judges who had passed the original reference order on 23 September. His central argument was that the judges who authored an order are best placed to reconsider it.

Bhushan flagged an additional urgency: Justice Sharma is due to retire at the end of next week. He urged CJI Kant to schedule the hearing before that date, arguing that a post-retirement consideration would render the recall effectively academic.

How the Court Responded

CJI Kant declined the request, observing that all objections to the reference order — including the recall application — could be raised before the already-constituted five-judge Constitution Bench. The CJI further indicated that the Constitution Bench retains the authority to consider the recall application even after Justice Sharma's retirement, effectively closing the door on a separate two-judge hearing.

The Conflict-of-Interest Allegation

The recall application does not merely contest the reference on procedural grounds. It specifically questions Justice Sharma's participation in the proceedings, alleging a conflict of interest on the ground that his son had appeared as standing counsel for the Election Commission of India (ECI). This allegation, if adjudicated by the Constitution Bench, could have significant implications for how the reference order itself is viewed.

Background: The Split Verdict and What the Law Changes

The underlying dispute concerns the 2023 Act, which altered the composition of the selection committee responsible for appointing the Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) and Election Commissioners (ECs). Crucially, the law replaced the Chief Justice of India in that panel with a Union Cabinet Minister nominated by the Prime Minister.

Petitioners argue this change structurally compromises the independence of the poll panel — an institution constitutionally mandated to ensure free and fair elections. The 23 September split verdict saw Justice Datta reject the plea for a larger-Bench reference, while Justice Sharma held that the challenge raised substantial questions of constitutional interpretation. The divergence led CJI Kant to constitute the five-judge Bench.

What Happens Next

The matter will now proceed before the five-judge Constitution Bench, which will hear both the main challenge to the 2023 appointment law and, reportedly, the recall application. The outcome could reshape the institutional balance between the judiciary, the executive, and India's constitutional election machinery for years to come.

Point of View

But it sidesteps a pointed question: can a Constitution Bench meaningfully review a reference order that is itself under challenge for a conflict of interest? By folding the recall into the larger five-judge hearing, the court avoids urgency but defers a credibility question that will not disappear. The 2023 law's removal of the CJI from the selection panel was always a live constitutional flashpoint; the institutional optics of adjudicating that law while one of the referring judges faces a bias allegation will follow the bench. Courts derive authority from perceived impartiality — the five-judge bench will need to address the conflict allegation head-on rather than let it linger as background noise.
NationPress
20 Nov 2026

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the CEC and EC Appointment Act, 2023, and why is it being challenged?
The Chief Election Commissioner and other Election Commissioners (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023 changed the composition of the selection committee for appointing the CEC and Election Commissioners. It replaced the Chief Justice of India on the panel with a Union Cabinet Minister nominated by the Prime Minister. Petitioners argue this compromises the independence of the Election Commission, which is constitutionally responsible for conducting free and fair elections.
Why did Prashant Bhushan want the recall plea heard urgently?
Bhushan sought an urgent listing before the original two-judge Bench because Justice Satish Chandra Sharma — one of the judges who passed the reference order — is due to retire at the end of next week. He argued that judges who authored an order are best placed to reconsider it, and that a post-retirement hearing would be practically meaningless.
What was the split verdict in the Supreme Court on 23 September?
On 23 September, Justices Dipankar Datta and Satish Chandra Sharma delivered a split verdict on whether the petitions challenging the 2023 appointment law required referral to a larger Bench. Justice Datta rejected the plea for a reference, while Justice Sharma held that the challenge raised substantial constitutional questions warranting a Constitution Bench. The disagreement led CJI Surya Kant to constitute a five-judge Bench.
What is the conflict-of-interest allegation against Justice Sharma?
The recall application alleges that Justice Sharma had a conflict of interest because his son appeared as standing counsel for the Election Commission of India — one of the key institutional parties connected to the dispute. The allegation forms a central ground for seeking reconsideration of the reference order he co-authored.
What happens to the case now?
The matter will proceed before the five-judge Constitution Bench already constituted by CJI Surya Kant. The bench is expected to hear both the primary constitutional challenge to the 2023 appointment law and the recall application, including the conflict-of-interest allegation against Justice Sharma.
Nation Press
The Trail

Connected Dots

Tracing the thread behind this story — newest first.

8 Dots
  1. Latest 1 month ago
  2. 1 month ago
  3. 1 month ago
  4. 6 months ago
  5. 8 months ago
  6. 1 year ago
  7. 1 year ago
  8. 1 year ago
Google Prefer NP
On Google