Shiv Sena (UBT) questions phone tapping legality, cites Telegraph and Telecom Acts
Synopsis
Key Takeaways
Shiv Sena (Uddhav Balasaheb Thackeray) on Monday, 16 November launched a sharp attack on Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Home Minister Amit Shah over allegations of illegal phone tapping, calling the purported practice an 'assault' on Indian democracy. The party's broadside came through an editorial in its official mouthpiece, 'Samaana', invoking specific legal provisions under Indian telecommunications law to argue that any surveillance targeting political opponents would be a criminal offence.
The Legal Argument
The editorial cited Section 5(2) of the Indian Telegraph Act, 1885, and Section 20 of the Telecommunication Act, 2023, arguing that lawful interception by central or state home secretaries is strictly confined to cases involving national security threats, sovereignty concerns, or public emergencies. The Thackeray camp contended that none of these conditions apply to political opponents, making any alleged monitoring of opposition leaders legally indefensible.
The editorial drew on recent claims by Rahul Gandhi, Leader of Opposition in the Lok Sabha, who reportedly alleged that incriminating evidence against PM Modi is stored on his phone and that authorities are attempting to access or erase it. The editorial framed these allegations as central to its case against the current administration.
Who May Be Under Watch, According to Samaana
The Thackeray camp went further, suggesting that alleged surveillance under the present government is not limited to opposition figures. The editorial claimed that prominent leaders within the ruling establishment — including Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath, Maharashtra Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis, Defence Minister Rajnath Singh, and senior military officers — may also be targets of such monitoring, though it provided no independent corroboration for these claims.
The Pegasus Reference and the Netanyahu Parallel
Recalling the controversy surrounding the Israeli-developed Pegasus spyware, reportedly introduced during PM Modi's tenure, the editorial drew a pointed parallel to the political fate of former Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. It argued that just as Netanyahu faced electoral defeat after allegedly targeting political rivals, similar political dynamics signal an impending reversal of fortune for India's current central leadership — and cited Rahul Gandhi as the figure poised to benefit.
Notably, this is not the first time Pegasus has featured in Indian political discourse. The spyware scandal first emerged in India in 2021, triggering parliamentary disruptions and demands for a Supreme Court-monitored probe, which the apex court later ordered.
Maharashtra's Past Controversies Revisited
The editorial also revisited older political battles in Maharashtra, accusing Devendra Fadnavis of deploying state police machinery and senior Director General of Police (DGP) officials — allegedly sent to Israel for phone-tapping training — to surveil political rivals and journalists during previous regime transitions. These are allegations Fadnavis has not publicly addressed in the context of this editorial, and they remain contested.
The Warning
Concluding with a stark warning, the Uddhav Thackeray-led party stated that if constitutional frameworks and democratic norms are subverted through what it described as 'authoritarian surveillance', public trust in governance would collapse. The editorial suggested this could ultimately drive citizens to the streets to overthrow what it termed a 'corrupt and tyrannical government'.
The BJP has not issued an immediate response to the Samaana editorial. As political temperatures rise ahead of ongoing state-level electoral cycles, the phone-tapping row is expected to remain a flashpoint in the Opposition's campaign narrative against the Centre.