Clarke links Steve Smith's New York life to Sandpapergate fallout

Share:
Audio Loading voice…
Clarke links Steve Smith's New York life to Sandpapergate fallout

Synopsis

Michael Clarke has gone further than most in explaining why Steve Smith calls New York home — framing it not as a lifestyle choice but as an escape from an Australian public that, in Clarke's words, has gone harder on the scandal than any other country would. With Khawaja's biography reopening old wounds and Smith staying conspicuously silent, the human cost of Sandpapergate is back in sharp focus.

Key Takeaways

Michael Clarke linked Steve Smith's New York residency to the lasting emotional fallout of the 2018 ball-tampering scandal .
Clarke said all three sanctioned players — Smith, Warner , and Bancroft — 'have been through some really tough times' and 'live with that forever.' Usman Khawaja's biography has reignited debate over who knew about sandpaper use in the Australian dressing room.
Khawaja disclosed an awkward pre-publication conversation with Smith; Warner and Pat Cummins have spoken publicly, but Smith has not.
Smith, 37 , is expected to play for New South Wales at the Sydney Cricket Ground from Sunday before Australia's first Test against New Zealand in Perth on 9 December .

Former Australia captain Michael Clarke believes the lingering emotional toll of the 2018 ball-tampering scandal may have played a significant role in Steve Smith's decision to make New York a second home, arguing that the batter sought distance from relentless public scrutiny in Australia that has never fully subsided.

Clarke's Remarks on Smith's New York Move

Speaking on 2DayFM Breakfast with Nath, Emma & Michael Clarke, Clarke reflected at length on the personal consequences of Sandpapergate for all three sanctioned players — Smith, David Warner, and Cameron Bancroft. 'I can guarantee you all three of them have been through some really tough times… you live with that forever,' Clarke said on Tuesday.

Clarke also offered a candid explanation for why Smith and his wife Dani have established a base in the United States. 'I think a part of why Steve Smith lives in New York is because when he retired, he doesn't want to go to a pub; a guy gets drunk at the pub and yells something across the bar,' Clarke said. He added: 'I feel for everyone involved, and it's not spoken about enough – their families. They're all involved. I can't imagine another country going as hard (at this scandal) as we have.'

What Reignited the Sandpapergate Debate

The controversy has resurfaced following the release of a biography by Usman Khawaja, which has reignited questions about how widely the use of sandpaper to alter the ball was known within the Australian dressing room during the South Africa tour. Khawaja recently disclosed that he had an awkward conversation with Smith ahead of the book's publication. Warner and current Test skipper Pat Cummins have both spoken publicly about their perspectives on the episode, while Smith has remained notably absent from the public discussion.

Smith's Current Situation and Cricket Schedule

Steve Smith, 37, who is originally from Sydney, maintains a residence in New York, where he spends a considerable portion of the year and has sporting and business interests. He featured in two of Australia's three Tests in South Africa last month before travelling to the US.

His return to competitive cricket in Australia is expected next week, with Smith likely to turn out for New South Wales in their Sheffield Shield fixture against Queensland at the Sydney Cricket Ground, beginning Sunday. He is then expected to be part of Australia's preparations for the first Test against New Zealand, scheduled to begin in Perth on 9 December.

The Wider Human Cost of the Scandal

Clarke's remarks are notable for the emphasis he placed on families of those involved — a dimension that rarely features in mainstream coverage of Sandpapergate. This comes amid a broader pattern in which the 2018 episode continues to cast a shadow over Australian cricket long after the formal suspensions concluded. The renewed scrutiny, driven in part by Khawaja's biography, suggests the full reckoning with Sandpapergate remains unfinished. Whether Smith will address the latest round of questions publicly before his upcoming assignments remains unclear.

Point of View

But the social cost for those involved has not. The fact that a former Australia captain is openly theorising that one of the country's greatest batters prefers a foreign city to avoid pub confrontations says something damning about how the affair was handled and how it continues to fester. Khawaja's biography is doing what official cricket channels have never done — forcing the dressing-room omerta into the open. Smith's silence ahead of his return to competitive cricket is itself a statement, and Australian cricket's administrators may soon face pressure to facilitate some form of genuine closure rather than allowing each book, interview or reunion to reopen the same wound.
NationPress
17 Nov 2026

Frequently Asked Questions

Why does Steve Smith live in New York, according to Michael Clarke?
Michael Clarke has suggested that Smith's New York base is at least partly a refuge from the intense and unrelenting public scrutiny he faces in Australia following the 2018 ball-tampering scandal. Clarke said Smith does not want to walk into a pub and have a stranger shout something at him about the controversy.
What is the Sandpapergate scandal?
Sandpapergate refers to the 2018 ball-tampering incident during Australia's Test tour of South Africa, in which players used sandpaper to illegally alter the condition of the ball. Steve Smith (then captain), David Warner (vice-captain), and Cameron Bancroft were the three players officially sanctioned with bans.
What has Usman Khawaja's biography revealed about Sandpapergate?
Khawaja's biography has reignited questions about whether others in the Australian dressing room were aware of the sandpaper use, beyond the three players who were sanctioned. Khawaja also disclosed that he had an awkward conversation with Steve Smith before the book was published.
When is Steve Smith expected to return to cricket in Australia?
Smith is expected to play for New South Wales in a Sheffield Shield match against Queensland at the Sydney Cricket Ground beginning Sunday. He is then likely to feature in Australia's preparations for the first Test against New Zealand in Perth, starting 9 December.
Has Steve Smith responded publicly to the latest Sandpapergate debate?
As of the latest reports, Smith has not spoken publicly about the renewed controversy triggered by Khawaja's biography, in contrast to Warner and Cummins who have shared their perspectives. It remains unclear whether Smith will comment before his upcoming cricket assignments.
Nation Press
The Trail

Connected Dots

Tracing the thread behind this story — newest first.

8 Dots
  1. Latest Yesterday
  2. 2 days ago
  3. 3 days ago
  4. 4 days ago
  5. 6 days ago
  6. 1 week ago
  7. 1 week ago
  8. 2 months ago
Google Prefer NP
On Google