Khawaja questions CA's Sandpapergate forum: 'Are we just going in a circle?'
Synopsis
Key Takeaways
Usman Khawaja has cast doubt over Cricket Australia's (CA) newly announced independent forum into the 2018 Sandpapergate scandal, questioning whether the process will produce transparent outcomes or simply allow the board to selectively control what becomes public. The remarks, made on 18 November, came just hours after CA unveiled the forum in response to Khawaja's explosive memoir.
What Khawaja's Memoir Revealed
In his book 'Sabr', Khawaja claims that the entire Australian Test squad was aware of the use of sandpaper during the 2018 Cape Town Test against South Africa — and alleges the same practice occurred in the previous Test in Port Elizabeth. The revelations have reignited fierce debate within cricket circles, with former opener David Warner — who served a 12-month ban for his role in the ball-tampering affair — publicly backing Khawaja's account.
CA Announces Independent Forum
On Wednesday, CA CEO Todd Greenberg and interim chair David Boon announced the creation of an independent forum that will allow players and support staff from the 2018 South Africa tour to rehear their testimonies. Crucially, CA clarified the forum would not reopen a formal investigation into the Cape Town incident — a distinction that has drawn scrutiny.
Khawaja's Concerns Over Transparency
Speaking on Fox Cricket during coverage of the final ODI between Australia and England in Hobart, Khawaja expressed measured scepticism. He said he welcomed the idea of a safe space for players to speak, but wished CA had announced it 'a week-and-a-half ago.'
'The public want to know what happened there. It's hard to get the whole truth unless everyone is speaking, support staff and players,' Khawaja said.
His central concern is that the CA board retains the power to determine which findings are made public. 'I could go in there and say something but then the board can decide that they're not gonna release that. And I just feel like then we just go in a circle again,' he said.
Khawaja also challenged the forum's framing directly: 'If you're gonna cherry pick what is said… the board can choose whatever they want to come in or come out, are we just going in a circle here?'
The Broader Context
The 2018 Cape Town Test remains one of cricket's most damaging episodes. Steve Smith, David Warner, and Cameron Bancroft received bans of 12 months, 12 months, and nine months respectively. Critics at the time argued the punishment was disproportionate and that responsibility was not evenly distributed across the squad — a view Khawaja's memoir appears to reinforce. This is notably the first time a sitting or former Australian cricketer of Khawaja's standing has directly implicated the broader touring party.
What Happens Next
Khawaja said he respects Greenberg's intent but indicated his participation hinges on greater clarity about governance of the forum's findings. Warner, now also speaking publicly, adds weight to calls for a fuller reckoning. Whether CA can design a process that earns the trust of those it needs to participate remains the key question heading into what could be the sport's most consequential accountability exercise in years.