Should Disasters Be Politicized? BJP Leaders Critique ST Hasan's Comments on Uttarakhand Cloudburst
Click to start listening
Synopsis
The comments made by ST Hasan regarding the Uttarkashi cloudburst have provoked fierce criticism from BJP leaders, who argue that such statements are damaging and politically motivated. This incident raises questions about the politicization of natural disasters in India, highlighting the need for unity during crises.
Key Takeaways
- ST Hasan's comments are viewed as divisive.
- BJP leaders argue that politicizing disasters is harmful.
- Ongoing rescue operations are crucial for affected individuals.
- Social unity is essential during crises.
- Natural disasters should not be used for political gain.
New Delhi, Aug 9 (NationPress) A provocative statement by former Samajwadi Party MP, ST Hasan, regarding the recent cloudburst in Uttarkashi has incited strong backlash from BJP leaders, who have labeled the comment as divisive, baseless, and politically motivated.
BJP MP Praveen Khandelwal reacted vehemently, asserting that Hasan’s assertion was entirely unfounded and an effort to introduce communal elements into a natural disaster.
“His claims are completely unfounded. Natural calamities can strike anywhere, and it is utterly erroneous to imply that any religion is being disrespected. Such remarks are designed to disrupt social harmony,” he stated.
Senior BJP figure Mukhtar Abbas Naqvi also denounced the comments.
“Whether in Uttarakhand or any other area facing calamities, individuals have endured significant hardships. While the nation prays for those impacted, some choose to hurl accusations. They present nonsensical arguments such as linking these disasters to unrelated geopolitical issues. What is occurring in Palestine? What is happening in Iraq? Why resort to such illogical reasoning?”
Uttar Pradesh Minister and Nishad Party chief Sanjay Nishad remarked: “It is inappropriate to make such claims; they are unfounded. These are the same individuals who persistently engage in politics even during crises.”
Earlier, in an interview with IANS, ST Hasan commented, “In Uttarakhand and Himachal Pradesh, other faiths are not being honored. There is a higher power governing the world, and when divine justice occurs, no one can shield themselves. Bulldozers should not be employed on any dargahs or temples. It’s preferable to evacuate such sites peacefully.”
The cloudburst in Uttarkashi has resulted in numerous fatalities, individuals missing, and many displaced.
Rescue operations are ongoing, with NDRF and SDRF units deployed in the affected areas. While leaders across the political spectrum have expressed their prayers and sympathies, Hasan’s remarks have been broadly interpreted as an attempt to communalize a natural calamity.
Point of View
It is crucial to maintain objectivity in reporting. The comments made by ST Hasan have sparked a significant debate about the intersection of politics and natural disasters. While it is essential to acknowledge the suffering of those affected, it is equally vital to refrain from exploiting such tragedies for political gain, as this can undermine societal unity.
NationPress
19/08/2025
Frequently Asked Questions
What was ST Hasan's comment regarding the Uttarkashi cloudburst?
ST Hasan suggested that other religions are not being respected in Uttarakhand and Himachal Pradesh, linking natural disasters to divine justice.
How did BJP leaders respond to Hasan's remarks?
BJP leaders, including Praveen Khandelwal and Mukhtar Abbas Naqvi, condemned Hasan's comments as baseless and politically motivated attempts to stir communal tensions.
What are the implications of politicizing natural disasters?
Politicizing natural disasters can lead to social discord and distract from the urgent need for humanitarian aid and support for affected communities.
What is the current status of the rescue operations in Uttarkashi?
Rescue operations are ongoing, with NDRF and SDRF teams actively working to locate missing individuals and provide assistance to the displaced.
Why is it important to maintain social harmony during disasters?
Maintaining social harmony during disasters is crucial for effective recovery efforts and for fostering a sense of community support among those affected.
