Pakistan's mediator role between Iran and US under fresh scrutiny
Synopsis
Key Takeaways
Pakistan's self-styled role as a mediator between Iran and the United States has come under renewed international scrutiny after reports emerged that an Iranian military aircraft was parked at Nur Khan Air Base near Rawalpindi, raising pointed questions about Islamabad's balancing act amid the ongoing West Asia conflict.
What the Reports Alleged
American broadcaster CBS reported on 11 May that Pakistan had permitted Iran to park its military aircraft on Pakistani airfields, potentially shielding them from US air strikes. The report, also cited by Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty, reignited a long-running debate in Washington over whether Islamabad can simultaneously sustain close security ties with the US while maintaining strategic relationships with America's adversaries.
Pakistan's Foreign Ministry Response
Pakistan's Foreign Ministry called the news report 'misleading and sensationalised,' though it stopped short of denying the aircraft's presence at the base. 'The Iranian aircraft parked in Pakistan arrived during the ceasefire period and bear no linkage whatsoever to any military contingency or preservation arrangement,' the ministry said in an official statement. The carefully worded denial — confirming the aircraft's presence while disputing its significance — drew immediate attention from analysts tracking the region.
US Senator Demands Full Reevaluation
US Senator Lindsey Graham responded sharply, posting on X: 'If this reporting is accurate, it would require a complete reevaluation of the role Pakistan is playing as mediator between Iran, the United States and other parties. Given some of the prior statements by Pakistani defense officials towards Israel, I would not be shocked if this were true.' Graham's remarks signal that the episode could complicate Pakistan's diplomatic positioning in Washington at a particularly sensitive moment.
The 'Double Game' Accusation Resurfaces
The controversy has revived accusations that Pakistan plays a 'double game' — a charge that has shadowed Islamabad since the US-led war on terror, when Pakistan was a non-NATO ally receiving substantial American security assistance. Tensions peaked in 2018 when then-President Donald Trump publicly accused Islamabad of taking billions in US aid while providing a 'safe haven' to militants in Afghanistan. Trump had posted on social media: 'The United States has foolishly given Pakistan more than 33 billion dollars in aid over the last 15 years, and they have given us nothing but lies and deceit, thinking of our leaders as fools.' The current episode echoes that fracture point, this time with Iran at the centre rather than Afghanistan.
What Happens Next
The episode puts Islamabad in a diplomatically precarious position: too close an association with Iran risks its standing in Washington, while distancing itself from Tehran could jeopardise its regional leverage. With the West Asia conflict still unresolved and US-Iran tensions running high, Pakistan's ability to credibly position itself as a neutral facilitator may now face its stiffest test yet.