COP31 Antalya: Fossil fuel phaseout talks stall as geopolitical tensions deepen
Synopsis
Key Takeaways
The UN Climate Change Conference (COP31) in Antalya, Turkey entered its final stretch on 19 November 2026 with ministers sharply divided over the pace of a global fossil fuel phaseout, even as the Turkish Presidency invoked the country's centuries-old Divan tradition to coax consensus from fractured delegations. The deepening standoff underscores a widening fault line between climate ambition and energy security that has shadowed every major COP since the Dubai agreement of 2023.
IEA Warning: Geopolitics Is Reshaping Energy Choices
Against that backdrop, the International Energy Agency (IEA) released its World Energy Outlook report on Thursday, examining how geopolitical conflicts, shifting risk perceptions and eroding trust among nations could redraw global energy markets for years to come. The report assessed how the evolving mix of fuels and technologies must respond to rapidly growing energy demand worldwide — even as governments argue about how fast to move away from hydrocarbons.
IEA Executive Director Fatih Birol offered a stark assessment: 'The Hormuz crisis has delivered a huge shock to the system. While the energy sector and the global economy have shown considerable resilience, the longer the crisis lasts, the deeper the effects will be. And I don't see any credible pathway for the energy world to return to the way it was before,' he said. The statement signals that supply disruptions — not just climate targets — are now a primary variable in the global energy equation.
Global Stocktake Launched, 21 Issues Still Unresolved
A day before the Divan session, nearly 200 nations formally launched the second five-yearly review of collective progress under the Paris Agreement, known as the Global Stocktake. The process is designed to benchmark where the world stands relative to its climate commitments and ratchet up ambition accordingly. At the time of the launch, 21 issues remained unresolved in the negotiations, with new draft texts due as ministers attempted to narrow differences across multiple tracks. Outside the venue, a large signed banner pressed civil society's core demand: protect workers and communities as economies transition to cleaner energy.
The Divan: Turkey's Ancient Counsel Tradition Meets Climate Diplomacy
COP31 President Murat Kurum and President of Negotiations Chris Bowen drew on Turkey's Divan tradition — a model of collective judgment with roots as far back as the 15th century — to structure informal, minister-level dialogue. The format, open to ministerial parties, negotiating group chairs and observer constituencies, was designed as a frank, party-driven and transparent space where delegations could articulate priorities without the procedural constraints of formal plenary sessions.
The best-known historical precedent is the Divan-ı Hümayun, or Ottoman Imperial Council, which deliberated on state affairs spanning diplomacy, finance, administration and justice — treating them as connected responsibilities rather than isolated domains. The Presidency consciously applied that integrative spirit to COP31's overlapping negotiating tracks, hoping ministers would surface areas of convergence before the final package is assembled.
Kurum told the assembled ministers: 'What we need at this stage is not so much to reiterate our respective positions, but rather to identify where we can move forward together. As we approach the final days of COP31, let us uphold the spirit of the Divan in our discussions here: let us listen to one another, broaden our common ground and translate what is possible into concrete outcomes.'
Bowen added: 'This is a chance for the world to show we can work together on climate change and deliver on the real economic and energy pressures people are facing. Now we need to build on common ground and deliver an ambitious, balanced and practical message to the world.'
What Remains at Stake
The core impasse at COP31 mirrors the tension that has defined post-Paris climate diplomacy: developed nations and climate-vulnerable states are pushing for faster fossil fuel elimination, while major emerging economies and energy-dependent nations argue that security of supply cannot be sacrificed on an accelerated timeline. The Hormuz crisis referenced by Birol has reinforced those concerns, giving energy-security arguments fresh political weight even among governments that had previously committed to ambitious phaseout timelines.
Notably, this is the second consecutive COP at which a fossil fuel phaseout text has stalled in the final week of negotiations, suggesting structural limits to multilateral consensus on the issue. How ministers use the remaining days — and whether the Divan process yields genuine movement — will determine whether Antalya becomes a milestone or another missed opportunity.