Pakistan a 'colonial, rent-seeking state': Analyst Ayesha Siddiqa at Hannover
Synopsis
Key Takeaways
Pakistani political analyst and author Ayesha Siddiqa delivered a sharp indictment of Pakistan's state structure at a conference in Hannover, Germany on 16 November 2026, describing it as a 'colonial and rent-seeking state' that has assumed the form of 'constitutional militarism'. The remarks, made at an event organised by the Baloch National Movement (BNM), drew attention to the military's entrenched dominance in Pakistani political and economic affairs.
Pakistan as a Bureaucratic Polity, Not a Political State
Siddiqa argued that Pakistan was never a genuine political state to begin with, saying it had functioned as a bureaucratic polity from its inception — a condition that made the military's outsized role structural rather than incidental. She said she had lost confidence in Pakistani authorities' ability to protect citizens or address their grievances.
She specifically condemned the forcible abduction of citizens by state agencies, saying such acts 'can never be justified.' Siddiqa further warned that state violence and authoritarianism had intensified over time, stating unequivocally that she no longer trusts the system.
Parliament, Judiciary and Civil Society 'Hollowed Out'
According to the BNM's account of her remarks, Siddiqa criticised Pakistan's political parties and parliament for effectively surrendering their authority. She said parliament had 'willingly approved restrictions on the media' and other measures at the military's behest. She added that institutions including the judiciary and civil bureaucracy had been systematically weakened, while an alliance of military and civilian elite interests now controls the distribution of national resources.
Mineral Resources, Enforced Disappearances and Resource Extraction
Siddiqa drew a direct link between enforced disappearances and the extraction of mineral wealth from Pakistan's peripheral provinces. She alleged that Pakistani authorities were prepared to sell mineral resources from Balochistan, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, and other regions without 'effective public consultation or accountability.'
Referring to a recent conference in Islamabad attended by Pakistani Army Chief Asim Munir, she said mineral resources were being offered to investors without taking parliament into confidence or consulting the communities living in the affected areas. She characterised 'fear, silence and repression' as deliberate tools used to sustain this process and shield those who control these resources.
Balochistan's Near-Invisibility in Global Media
Spanish journalist Karlos Zurutuza, who has reported from Balochistan, also addressed the event, noting that the province remains 'almost invisible' in international media despite its strategic significance and the acute dangers facing reporters there.
Zurutuza cited cases of New York Times correspondents facing serious obstacles, including reporter Carlotta Gall, who he said was beaten and expelled in 2006, and another reporter expelled after filing a single story. He also cited figures from Freedom Network, an Islamabad-based media watchdog, stating that at least 40 journalists have been killed in Balochistan over the past two decades.
Context: Baloch Martyrs' Day
The Hannover conference was held to mark Baloch Martyrs' Day, observed on 13 November each year by Baloch communities worldwide in tribute to those who lost their lives in the struggle for rights, dignity, and freedom in Balochistan. This year's gathering drew international voices raising concerns about state accountability, enforced disappearances, and media freedom in Pakistan's restive southwestern province. The event reflects a growing pattern of diaspora-led advocacy bringing Baloch rights issues to European platforms — a trend that Pakistani authorities have consistently contested.