US Senate rejects Iran war-powers resolution 48-51 in first post-midterm vote
Synopsis
Key Takeaways
The US Senate on Thursday, 21 November voted 48-51 to reject H.Con.Res. 93, a House-passed resolution that would have directed President Donald Trump to withdraw American forces from hostilities with Iran. The defeat marks the Senate's first war-powers vote since the 3 November midterm elections — and the 15th such vote overall since the conflict began.
How the Vote Broke Down
Three Republicans crossed the aisle to support the resolution: Senator Susan Collins of Maine, Senator Lisa Murkowski of Alaska, and Senator Rand Paul of Kentucky. On the Democratic side, Senator John Fetterman of Pennsylvania voted against the measure, while Senator Chris Murphy of Connecticut was declared 'necessarily absent' and did not vote.
Notably, Republican Senator Thom Tillis of North Carolina — who had backed a similar resolution (H.Con.Res. 89) in September — voted against this one. That earlier measure had failed 49-50 on 24 September.
Key Arguments on the Senate Floor
Democratic Senator Tim Kaine of Virginia urged colleagues to 'do what the Constitution demands, what our public demands, and that is to end this illegal war.' Kaine added, 'The American public is tired of it. But we here in the Senate, we have the capacity to fix it, and voting again that this war is illegal is an important step on the road to doing just that.'
Democratic Senator Tammy Baldwin of Wisconsin stated on the floor that the war 'has cost taxpayers at least $47 billion' and that '23 Americans have lost their lives.'
On the opposing side, Republican Senator Tim Sheehy of Montana urged a no vote, arguing: 'Iran is not a war of choice; it is a war of necessity. We should finish the job, protect this Nation, and protect our allies.' Sheehy warned that if Iran seized control of the Strait of Hormuz and other key sea lanes, it would 'constrict half the world's energy supply.'
Background and Legislative History
The resolution was introduced by Democratic Representative Seth Moulton of Massachusetts on 28 April. The House passed it by 220-204 on 15 September. As a concurrent resolution, it invoked Section 5(c) of the 1973 War Powers Resolution and, by design, would not have required the President's signature — meaning Trump could not have vetoed it.
According to the office of Senator Adam Schiff, the Senate has now cast 15 votes aimed at forcing an end to the conflict through the War Powers Resolution framework. The only measure to pass the Senate was H.Con.Res. 86, which the chamber adopted 50-48 on 23 June.
Democrats Signal Next Steps
Following the vote, Democrats signalled a renewed push once they assume congressional control in January. 'While we had bipartisan support in today's vote, it was not enough. In the new Congress, we will change that,' Schiff said in a statement.
Kaine said he and colleagues 'in the new Democratic majority Congress will be exploring every possible additional tool to force an end to the war.' Democratic Senator Jacky Rosen of Nevada said voters had 'resoundingly rejected Donald Trump's unconstitutional war with Iran that has made everything more expensive.'
The vote came a day after Indian American Congressman Ro Khanna and Democratic Representative Yassamin Ansari announced they would oppose any government funding package that did not explicitly prohibit spending on offensive operations in Iran. With current federal funding set to expire on 11 December, the Iran war question is now entangled with the broader government shutdown standoff.