Cauvery water dispute: SC defers Tamil Nadu plea to Aug 17
Synopsis
Key Takeaways
The Supreme Court on Wednesday, 12 August deferred to 17 August the hearing on Tamil Nadu's petition seeking directions to Karnataka to release 26.954 tmcft of Cauvery water. The adjournment came after Chief Justice of India (CJI) Surya Kant informed both parties that Justice Vikram Nath, who was scheduled to hear the matter on 13 August, had fallen ill.
What Tamil Nadu Has Sought
Senior advocate P. Wilson, appearing for Tamil Nadu, also brought to the court's notice a separate application filed by farmers in connection with the long-running Cauvery water dispute. The CJI agreed to tag the farmers' application with the state government's main petition, consolidating both before the bench.
Tamil Nadu approached the apex court contending that Karnataka had failed to comply with directions issued by the Cauvery Water Regulation Committee (CWRC) and the Cauvery Water Management Authority (CWMA).
The Regulatory Orders Karnataka Allegedly Ignored
According to Tamil Nadu's petition, the CWRC, at its 139th meeting held on 28 July, reviewed hydrological and meteorological conditions in the Cauvery basin and directed Karnataka to ensure a flow of 3,500 cusecs at Biligundlu for 15 days, from 29 July to 12 August. Karnataka was specifically instructed to regulate releases from the Krishnaraja Sagar (KRS) and Kabini reservoirs to maintain that stipulated flow.
The CWMA, at its 54th emergency meeting on 30 July, examined basin conditions and endorsed the CWRC's recommendation. Tamil Nadu alleged that the actual quantity of water received at Biligundlu after these orders was far below its rightful share.
Reservoir Levels and Tamil Nadu's Argument
Tamil Nadu submitted that as of 3 August, Karnataka's four major Cauvery basin reservoirs together held 77.537 tmcft of water — with total utilisable storage stated at 67.517 tmcft. The breakdown: KRS reservoir at 23.078 tmcft, Kabini at 18.610 tmcft, Harangi at 7.827 tmcft, and Hemavathi at 28.022 tmcft.
The state argued that with such storage levels — bolstered by heavy rainfall recorded in the catchment areas of the KRS and Kabini reservoirs — Karnataka would face no difficulty in releasing its proportionate share. Based on the prevailing hydrological conditions and the prescribed sharing formula, Tamil Nadu maintained it should receive 26.954 tmcft at Biligundlu.
Why Tamil Nadu Calls the CWMA Order 'Grossly Inadequate'
Tamil Nadu pointed out that the release directed by the CWMA — 3,500 cusecs for 15 days — would amount to only approximately 4.536 tmcft, which it described as grossly inadequate given its computed entitlement. The state has urged the Supreme Court to issue directions to Karnataka to immediately release the full 26.954 tmcft and ensure compliance with CWMA and CWRC orders.
What Happens Next
The matter is now listed for hearing on 17 August. The consolidation of the farmers' application with the state petition signals that the court may take a broader view of the dispute's ground-level impact when arguments are eventually heard.