Tharoor Questions Goyal: FTAs Without Reform Won't Lift Exports
Synopsis
Key Takeaways
India keeps signing trade deals. The export numbers are not keeping up — and Congress MP Dr. Shashi Tharoor wants to know why Commerce and Industry Minister Piyush Goyal is treating those two halves of his portfolio as if they belong to different governments.
The FTA Paradox: More Deals, Same Bottlenecks
Writing in an opinion piece published on Saturday, 21 November 2026, Tharoor argues that India's expanding web of Free Trade Agreements has failed to meaningfully improve the country's export figures or deepen its integration into global value chains. His diagnosis is blunt: 'domestic industry is still held back by regulatory cholesterol and corruption.' The deals are in place. The domestic engine is not firing.
India has accelerated FTA signings since 2020, part of a strategic push to embed the country in global supply chains. The Comprehensive Economic Partnership Agreement with the UAE, signed in 2022, was held up as a template — aimed at doubling bilateral trade. The Production Linked Incentive (PLI) schemes, also launched in 2020, were designed to build the manufacturing muscle that would let Indian firms actually exploit those market-access windows. The results, across sectors, have been mixed.
One Minister, Two Mandates — and a Sharp Question
Tharoor's sharpest rhetorical move is to address Goyal not once but twice — acknowledging him as Commerce Minister before immediately pivoting to his second hat as Industry Minister. 'You're doing well as Commerce Minister, signing FTAs,' Tharoor writes, 'but what are you doing as Industry Minister to help Indian businesses compete globally, so India can benefit from these FTAs?' It is a precise structural critique: trade access means nothing if the exporter back home cannot clear a regulatory queue or navigate a corrupt approval chain.
The broader pattern is well-established in policy circles. Market-access agreements lower tariff walls abroad, but Indian exporters still face high logistics costs, inconsistent standards enforcement, and compliance burdens that erode the price advantage those agreements are supposed to create. A tariff concession abroad is worthless if the cost of doing business at home wipes it out.
What the Pending EU and UK Deals Will Test
The stakes are rising. India is in advanced negotiations on FTAs with both the European Union and the United Kingdom — two of the world's most demanding trade partners when it comes to product standards, labour norms, and supply-chain transparency. If domestic regulatory reform does not accelerate in parallel, critics argue, those agreements risk repeating the same gap Tharoor describes: headline deals that underdeliver on ground-level export growth.
The next Union Budget will be a key test — whether the government pairs any new trade-deal announcements with concrete ease-of-doing-business measures or regulatory simplification that manufacturers and exporters can actually feel.
Tharoor's column frames the challenge cleanly: global ambition requires domestic fitness. India cannot sprint on the world trade track while its industry is still warming up in a bureaucratic waiting room.